Replying to Avatar Josephus

That’s not my argument. Quite the strawman. I posted an article on political theory and your theory is “it’s everyone but white people”, ie “deport everyone else and everything will resolve itself miraculously”, which is horseshit. Youre strawmanning me to pull yourself out of your own ridiculous nonsense that somehow the ONLY issues with anything and everything in white civilization is some other ethnicity, as if Rome didnt fall on its own accord, as if Europe never had ideological issues of its own accord, as if the sophists weren’t such a bad native local problem that Plato had to draw from oriental mystery religions to solve them, etc.

I tried to offer an ideological solution and you want to make everything race, which is bullshit because the ideological problems CREATED the immigration and ghetto-ization issues that made race a problem domestically in the first place. But you’d rather scapegoat any issue ever than address them for real or use real logic. You didn’t mention a SINGLE thing from the article you commented on, not once.

The point of my historical examples was to show that ideology plays just as much if not a bigger role than race. But wanted to play semantic technicality games rather than accept that white people could be fallible in any capacity. Your own line of argument about Jews implies they are a super race with psychic powers… if whites can not be faulted for having poor ideological principles that allowed a Jewish takeover, than innate jewish supremacy is the logical conclusion of YOUR argument.

You are acting like one of those “free Palestine” or “eat the rich” shit posters who raid a perfectly normal and unrelated conversation and making sure that no broad scope conversation can take place without YOU being front and center and YOUR “silver bullet” solution is the only permitted topic of conversation.

There is no silver bullet. If Hitler or someone else succeeded in genociding all the blacks and all the Jews, there would STILL be problems. The USA had a constitutional crisis under JACKSON with no Jews in power and no blacks allowed to vote. Some things require actually thinking about the thing itself instead of scapegoating other people. Get over yourself.

It’s not a strawman it’s a perfect summary of your argument so far.

Though your replies are strawmen and show a lack of understanding of the argument at hand.

Even your conclusion with your rant here: “even if… THERE WOULD STILL BE PROBLEMS.”

Of course there would be problems, no one said there wouldn’t be. No one said it’s ALL of X group either.

The question is: What problems do you want to have. That’s it.

Black problems where if our entire country was blacks we’d be the most violent and dangerous country in the world? Jewish problems where if everyone was Jewish we’d all be tranny faggots and create divisions amongst ourselves because “we can’t all be chosen.”

Or, Christian white problems where we live generally rationally and peacefully amongst each other.

There will always be problems, you just have to choose the best option amongst them, and you have to recognize certain groups cause significantly more problems than others.

Reply to this note

Please Login to reply.

Discussion

You haven’t addressed my actual argument for one second. My argument was that ideology matters more and that we should be focusing on the metaphysics and epistemology, and political organization issues first and foremost. My article you responded to didnt even mention race one way or the other. Would it work better in a totally white nation? Sure. You are the one who rabbit holed this about race when it wasn’t about race, misidentified my own race, and refuse to actually return to topic on philosophical and political theory because you want to act like a retarded hammer when you can’t find any nails in my article. Fuck off.

So, ideology is the only factor?

What’s your ideal ideology here?

Not the only factor, but the most important. Blacks were more civil when they had more successfully assimilated into white society in the past. They have become more barbaric on average when they converted to new Afro-communism. Race is a factor, but that change within 2 generations shows that ideology is a bigger one.

Ideal

Metaphysics: finite universe, monist (as opposed to duelist) meaning no mind/dichotomy: mind and spirit are different but inextricably linked. Brain death is lie from the medical industry for organ harvesting: your mind and body are one synchronous whole (within this truth is where ideology is important but ALSO how race plays a role).

Epistemology: the attributes ARE the thing (as opposed to Plato’s forms), the concept is your acknowledgement of the truth of the attributes (this topic can be an article by itself).

Politics: A general merger of the original intent of the US founding fathers, but with some inspiration from Heinlein regarding “skin in the game with the franchise” (again, a whole article or several in and of itself).

I’ll leave it at that for now until I have the time to actually write full length explanations on some of these concepts.