Avatar
Super Testnet 4mo ago 💬 22

At least 10 devs deliberately contribute to Knots:

1 x.com/LukeDashjr, https://github.com/luke-jr

2 x.com/leo_haf, https://github.com/retropex

3 x.com/bigshiny90, https://github.com/bigshiny90

4 x.com/009Ataraxi71445, https://github.com/ataraxia009

5 https://github.com/pithosian

6 x.com/cguida6, https://github.com/chrisguida

7 x.com/1440000bytes, https://github.com/1440000bytes

8 x.com/dr0ther, https://github.com/dr0ther

9 x.com/Kurtis_NZ, https://github.com/KurtisStirling

10 https://github.com/kwsantiago

Any others?

Reply to this note

Please Login to reply.

Discussion

Avatar
Trazyn 4mo ago

Looking at the repo I see just luke doing commits ? What evidence do you have of other contributors ?

Avatar
Super Testnet 4mo ago 💬 1

for each one, I linked to their githubs so that you can review their contributions.

Here are some examples of each person's contributions:

- leo_haf got this code merged: https://github.com/bitcoinknots/guix.sigs/pull/32

- bigshiny90 got this code merged: https://github.com/bitcoinknots/guix.sigs/pull/37

- ataraxia got this code merged: https://github.com/bitcoinknots/guix.sigs/pull/38

- pithosian created this pull request, which has not yet been merged: https://github.com/bitcoinknots/bitcoin/pull/135

- Chris Guida reviewed the above-mentioned pull request

- Floppy Disk Guy reviewed it too

- dr0ther created this docker container for Knots: https://github.com/dr0ther/bitcoin-knots-docker

- Kurtis worked on the font and imagery used in Knots: https://github.com/KurtisStirling/Bitcoin-Knots-Brand/commits?author=KurtisStirling

- kwsantiago created this pull request, which has not yet been merged: https://github.com/bitcoinknots/bitcoin/pull/154

Avatar
Trazyn 4mo ago

one of those merges is generating sigs on some files.

Be serious, contributions are code or code adjacent things

you're presenting these people as contributors for doodling in the margins.

Avatar
Super Testnet 4mo ago

If your only objection is that the example I gave for Leo wasn't actually code, I hope the attached post strengthens the case. Let me know if any of the others shouldn't count. nostr:nevent1qy28wumn8ghj7un9d3shjtnyv9kh2uewd9hsqg9wzn440g997td6nfp03gd668etluqj43w23ajf4ny8s0ukynujtsk34ajg

Avatar
Léo 4mo ago

For me this is code signature so it’s not really a code contribution, here is a real PR with code that have been added to the latest RC

https://github.com/bitcoinknots/bitcoin/pull/151

(Due to how Luke rebase Knots, the PR won’t be merged on GitHub but directly added to the tag) here is the relevant commit:

https://github.com/bitcoinknots/bitcoin/commit/96ebf21c6546ff6c5c21027b497bf6f78a735876

Avatar
moonsettler 4mo ago

there is also https://github.com/lnhance/bitcoinknots-bitcoin but we are not sending stuff upstream.

Avatar
Super Testnet 4mo ago

nice!

tell me more about your fork

why did you make it?

Avatar
moonsettler 4mo ago

i don't remember what i was thinking. but clearly i was mistaken.

Avatar
CptKook 4mo ago

The real MVPs

Avatar
Sly Fawkes 4mo ago

Only one Knots Dev myth busted.

Avatar
Super Testnet 4mo ago

BTW I include the word "deliberately" because, in an important way, Knots has a bunch of "accidental" contributors. Basically everyone who contributes to Bitcoin Core also contributes to Knots, knowingly or not, because Knots is mostly just Core with some patches.

Avatar
R 4mo ago

And when 7 of them think there is a problem with Luke’s update and Luke thinks it should get published, which way will it go?

Avatar
Modus 4mo ago

It can go to a fork, just like knots itself

Avatar
jb55 4mo ago

what do you think

ad
ade44633... 4mo ago

I'm asking for the last time send me a picture message for your gift package 📦 so you can receive it today or tomorrow okay 🆗📦📦

Massage me Whatsapp

https://wa.me/+1(541)9693337

https://wa.me/+1(541)9693337

https://wa.me/+1(541)9693337

https://wa.me/+1(541)9693337

https://wa.me/+1(541)9693337

https://wa.me/+1(541)9693337

https://wa.me/+1(541)9693337

https://wa.me/+1(541)9693337

Avatar
hasky 3mo ago

This is knots contributor

Avatar
hasky 3mo ago

Regardless Knot or Core .. the crypto always problem . There should not be so much coin in circulation that people can just issues coin as they want ! It is not sustainable to fraud for the user !!!