#vlog 22

Do Filters Work?

https://blossom.primal.net/009e037f0bdc98bb040379217b4cedd0b758aab195955003a521e78d668ce029.mov

Reply to this note

Please Login to reply.

Discussion

What do you define as spam?

Non-Bitcoin transactions, non-monetary transactions. JPEGs are spam on Bitcoin Monetary network. Other big data files and blobs as well. Bitcoin Knots allows 42 Bytes for hashes, which is acceptable.

Knots is configurable and makes it up to the user which is the main principle to adhere to.

Soo does that mean the OP_return in the genesis block considered spam?

No, that is part of those 42 Bytes (the default setting) for hashes, which is acceptable and which continues the Satoshi legacy.

I dont know man. My logic is if isn't broken, dont fix it.

If someone wants to do NFTs do it on a another chain 😆

Yes. Bitcoin is Money, Freedom Money, not a memecoin.

Also we can learn from BSV shitcoin experience

That message is in the coin base portion, not via op_return. Not the same thing.

Well said. There is an element of perfect solution fallacy in the counter filter narrative.

No puedo subtitular todos tus videos 😂

Thank you Jimmy 🫡

So simple.

Good approach, good point to consider nuances, but you didn't go deep enough. Consider the cost of node runners as well. Consider opportunity cost as well

E.g.: if there is a widespread filter for OpReturn, there is a cost to bypass that. But there is also an opportunity cost of using another method, that is a more convoluted (higher cost) but not filtered (less cost), such as embedding data in fake output keys (net less cost). But this solution has a higher cost for the node runners (in the form of non-prunable fake UTXO).

The lock on the door analogy is quite good, but how about this analogy: in some places people deliberately leave their cars window open when they know there is not much to steal from the car: they leave the car open not to _facilitate_ burglary, on the contrary, to _reduce_ the damage due to burglary (a broken window is costly to fix). I view leaving the filters open as a way to reduce the cost of other, more damaging actions.

Thank you sir !

I wonder if core devs consider Jimmy to be “not technical enough” to opine on the issue of filters 🤭

nostr:nevent1qqsq33qgewsrcu07h8y0fxjetsmandud08pyeesrdhg04qftlexyxggpr9mhxue69uhhyetvv9ujuam9d3kx7unyv4ezumn9ws8m3cmd

The only thing you forgot to say in this video

Run Knots and obliterate shitcoin core.

Run Bitcoin Knots to keep Bitcoin free of spam.

Thanks Jimmy for talking about the important stuff!

Excellent video, with just what I want. Considered reasoning on the tradeoffs at the heart of this.

For everyone reading this… Jimmy is PODCONF Approved ✅

Over the target

I want to share my experience with 𝐂𝐚𝐭𝐡𝐞𝐫𝐢𝐧𝐞 𝐄. 𝐑𝐮𝐬𝐬𝐞𝐥𝐥👥What'sApp page +44 7480735379 . Get the edge in crypto trading chat, who has been an exceptional crypto trader. Her trading signals are incredibly accurate, and especially now with Bitcoin soaring, she has helped me generate significant profits. Catherine is honest, trustworthy, and truly committed to her clients’ success. She is not a scam or an imposter—she’s the real deal and genuinely cares about helping people. If you’re considering crypto trading, don’t miss this opportunity. Reach out to her on WhatsApp page and see for yourself!

Bitcoin Knots and the filters it has work. Here is why:

nevent1qqsq33qgewsrcu07h8y0fxjetsmandud08pyeesrdhg04qftlexyxggpr9mhxue69uhhyetvv9ujuam9d3kx7unyv4ezumn9ws8m3cmd

Jimmy is trying to calm the situation to let the rationality flow.

Run Knots.