The simplest way to achieve this would be to gift-wrap (NIP-59) the event to each of the recipients.

You create your kind 31922 event, then wrap it in a kind 13 seal using the event creator's real key (encrypted via NIP-44 to the recipient). Next, you wrap that in a kind 1059 using a one-time key (nip-44 encrypted to the recipient, again), and finally tag it with the recipient's #p tag.

You would do this for each recepient of the event.

The relay is only responsible for forwarding messages; everything else is outside its concern. The group member list is determined by the group owner.

If the user opens the group client, it only needs to fetch messages from multiple relays—specifically, messages from the last timestamp up to the current time. The client then uses the messages from whichever relay responds the fastest.

> The main advantage is message stability and consistency.

🤔🤔🤔 Don’t think so.

Can 0xChat’s NIP-29 group work with multiple relays?

By the way, do you prefer group support for a single relay or multiple relays?

Au contraire, that's what I like most about it. NIP 28 will allow me to use less opinionated relays (that don't rely on RPC calls that have to be supported by the implementation).

Strongly considering abandoning nip 29 for nip 28 if you can believe it

k80pro

先清除数据重新登陆不行，后来卸载重装，还是老问题，不知道是不是我手机问题。

嗯，我试试看，sat倒不多，也不大会设置，用其他app也发不出，基本闲置😅

0xchat原来挺好，后来不知道什么原因，只要点钱包就闪退。

大概看了下 MLS，感觉需要维护很多东西，比如密钥树、加入以来所有 epoch 密钥…… nostr 这样的网络能稳定运行吗哈哈哈

基于 relay 还是基于密码学？

如果朋友很多的话，以加密方式发送一条朋友圈太不优雅了🤣 每个朋友都需要加密发送一个一样内容的 event。我觉得 lockbox 的方式比较优雅，但不是绝对的私密

呀～，😂

0xchat是比較類似，如果去掉公共部分。

微信首先是封閉的，內容只能朋友可見。0xchat加密信息可以實現，就算使用公共relay也沒關係。。

Concept sounds straightforward and extremely appealing.

Extend the simplicity to app start and onboarding, like

- 1 tap onboarding, make all profile information entries strictly optional, like name, bio.

- Faster app start with no splash screen

Other ideas

- Optional BOLT12 payment address field? Just to finally give BOLT12 so traction

- Message reactions and replies

- photo, video, PDF files copy paste support

- no stickers, gif libraries distractions