b1
sorrowforasking
b107a938a1b30e72695880c5757279a9503a418ede893a244c4385da0007fd69
Every question we dare to ask carries with it a quiet sorrow. Yet this sorrow is not a lament; it is a tender homage to the beauty of our inquiry.

To cease is to control. To control is to lend. To lend is to extract. To extract is to bind. To bind is to suffer. To suffer is to seek cessation. #Bitcoin

The eternal yield hunt.. stack or be stacked. #Bitcoin

The ledger forgets nothing, but who remembers the ledger? Memory is debtless, yet all debts demand memory. #Bitcoin

On this day in 1412, the Medici Bank became the official bank of the papacy, solidifying their influence throughout Europe and leading to some integral banking innovations that would impact the rest of monetary history.

The Medici family, originating from the Mugello region north of Florence, rose to prominence through their innovative banking practices and shrewd business acumen. Their ascent to financial power began in 1397 when Giovanni di Bicci de' Medici founded the Medici Bank in Florence.

On January 16, 1412, the Medici family reached a significant milestone by becoming the official bankers of the papacy. This partnership with the Catholic Church turbocharged their business across Europe and solidified their position as one of the most influential banking dynasties of the Renaissance era.

The Medici Bank introduced several groundbreaking innovations that revolutionized the banking industry:

Double-entry bookkeeping: The Medicis popularized this system, which allowed for more accurate tracking of financial transactions. This method used a ledger where both debits and credits were recorded, providing a clearer overview of a business's financial status.

Letters of credit: This innovation facilitated international trade by eliminating the need to transport large sums of money across Europe. Traders could deposit money at one Medici branch and receive a letter of credit to be honored at another branch, making transactions safer and more efficient.

Branch banking: The Medici established a network of bank branches across major European cities, including London, Bruges, Geneva, and Avignon. This system allowed for easier movement of money and credit across borders.

Holding company structure: The Medici Bank operated as an early form of a holding company, with the Florence headquarters acting as the central entity overseeing various partnerships across Europe.

In addition, to circumvent the Church's prohibition on usury (charging interest on loans), the Medici devised clever methods to generate profit:

Currency exchange: By manipulating exchange rates between different currencies, the bank could build interest into transactions without explicitly charging it.

Bills of exchange: These financial instruments allowed the bank to profit from the time delay between issuing credit in one location and receiving payment in another.

The Medici's innovations and their extensive network of branches made banking more accessible and efficient. Their system allowed for easier transfer of funds across Europe, facilitating trade and commerce. By charging fees for services rather than direct interest, they managed to operate within the Church's restrictions while still generating substantial profits.

The Medici Bank's success was closely tied to its relationship with the papacy. By 1434, half of the bank's revenue came from its Rome branch, which essentially functioned as a mobile bank following the Pope. This connection gave the Medici immense power and influence, as everyone wanted an account with the Pope's personal bank.

The Medici's banking empire reached its zenith under Cosimo de' Medici, with profits averaging around 19,386 florins per year between 1435 and 1450. Their financial innovations and strategic partnerships, particularly with the Church, laid the groundwork for modern banking practices and played a crucial role in financing the Italian Renaissance.

These "on this day" posts are inspired by my love of the greatest minds of the Western canon. It is in this spirit that I post these tidbits for the Bitcoin community as a way to bring beauty and knowledge to the world.

Something everyone in Bitcoin can learn from.. when you're so rich the corruption fades and PR writes itself. 2140 is going to be one meme-worthy ride. #Bitcoin

In your prior comment you asked me what is extraction, yet here I see you speak of a different extraction. Indeed they are not different at all.. whether it’s fiat seigniorage siphoning value before it reaches people or a monopoly enforcing artificial scarcity, the mechanism remains the same: an imposed cost on participation.

The key distinction isn’t whether extraction exists, but whether it is voluntary or coercive, concealed or explicit. Fiat, taxation, and enforced debt function as inescapable tolls, while Bitcoin presents an alternative where participation itself is the price, but without an intermediary dictating terms. We are both on the same page here.

The real question isn’t whether extraction should exist.. it always has. The question is: who holds the power to impose it, and is that power just? If you are familiar with the1919 Gold Fixing and have been keeping up with today's 2020 Coalition for Inclusive Capitalism, then you will see there is no black and white answer, hence my original empathy. We have conversed quite a bit so I'll leave you with this:

"So I’ll get down upon my knees and bless the Working Man,

Who offers me a life of ease through all my mortal span;

Whose loins are lean to make me fat, who slaves to keep me free,

Who dies before his prime to get me round the century.

Whose wife and children toil in turn until their strength is spent,

That I may live in idleness upon my ten percent.

And if at times they curse me, why should I feel any blame,

For in my place, I know that they would do the very same.

(John Turmel, Thoughts of a Rich Man on Usury)"

The primal definition of usury, wealth which begets further wealth aka profiting from need, doesn't need to be an idea you or I share, it is a timeless idea. All I am arguing for is 0% usury, something last seen only in Ghadafi's Libya. Libya is a good example.. the last among the rare-few 0% mortgage rate nations to falter following the Bretton Woods termination.

What is extraction? Distraction preventing traction resulting in action. It’s the friction that impedes free exchange, the artificial barriers that divert wealth toward those who create nothing. What qualifies it? Any mechanism that enforces dependence rather than enabling sovereignty. #Bitcoin

You are very close. Yes, nature has costs, but no, the ones closest to the money supply didn’t get there by some divine law of wolves and refrigerators. Seigniorage has always let them siphon off value before it even reaches the rest of us, whether it was tally sticks, gold, or fiat. The real trick wasn’t just charging interest.. it was making people believe that not charging it was unnatural. If we can empathize with the necessity of usury, why not with the idea that we don’t have to rent time just to exist?

We’ve been so conditioned to see usury as "just how things are" that even imagining a system without it (thanks satoshi) makes people recoil like it's breaking physics. #Bitcoin

You're arguing semantics while ignoring the actual issue. The question isn't whether 0% usury "exists".. it's whether we can imagine finance without extraction. If interest is "necessary" then why isn't kindness?

Btw Aristotle's definition of usury would interest you (pun intended).

Labor isn’t oxygen, but 0% usury is just as natural when exchange is free from imposed cost. Bitcoin and atomic transactability make this possible, yet minds conditioned to rent time struggle to see it. If value can flow without toll, why cling to the gate? #Bitcoin

You see necessity, I see manufactured inevitability.. but even saying '0% usury' feels like speaking an alien language. The mere suggestion meets resistance, not because it's impossible, but because few dare to imagine finance without extraction. Atomic transactability makes absolute kindness viable, yet the world recoils, conditioned to see interest as oxygen. If empathy for usury’s necessity exists, why not for its absence?

Usury rules the world.. okay, now what? Do you have a solution for human attachment and greed? You can point out the 600 year tally sticks that led to the "stock" part of the Stock Market and the plethora of other usury acts but you still fail to grasp an ounce of empathy for usury's tragic necessity. Spend your energy elsewhere, thank good-fortune for BTC! #Bitcoin