Why would it be disappointing? I'm not looking for excuses to avoid it, I'm merely pointing out a key factor for Pubky's growth. I'm sure we can agree on that.
Discussion
Thank you for your concern, but again, the Pubky protocol is already open-sourced, so you are raising the alarm about one repo of unfinished code for a new app that isn't ready for use - AND all of its testing users have access to that code too if they want.
The PKARR aspect itself, one of the most novel aspects, has been open-sourced for a lot longer and has been proposed to Nostr devs for more than a year.
What makes Nostr people interested in other things is simply whether they were made by Nostr people for Nostr people - it isn't science, it's loyalty.
I'm interested in pubky and I consider myself a nostr person
I think some of the ideas you guys have implemented are great and the rest are reasonable
I hope nostr becomes more like pubky in respect to the pubky ideas that I think are better and I hope pubky continues to improve
May the best protocol win