Both BTC and XMR have a relative and distinct value to what is perceived the dominant medium of exchange which makes it the UoA.

Change it for something else, gold, a CBDC, Bitcoin or Monero and you'll get to tally different relative valuations.

Everything is in flux.

(1) Normally we see fluctuations within the dominant MoE.

Meaning USD adoption gets bigger or smaller. Or there is more or less friction compared to its former self (AML), which then creates opportunity for competing MoE systems.

This is where BTC rose to prominence and where we compare Bitcoin vs USD (better protection against inflation, less acceptance) and Monero vs USD (better privacy, less acceptance)

(2) Then there are special times where the dominant MoE reached its end of lifecycle. In this scenario we can expect a nonlinear adjustment of valuations.

Meaning we get to choose a new dominant medium of exchange that ideally needs to check more boxes than the one before. In blockchain based systems we have the hard problem of scalability with self-custody and the soft problem of aceptance (that's only hindered on the social level through USD paid regulators).

Imagine a world where any of the following mediums becomes the new UoA.

1) Gold

2) CBDC

3) Bitcoin

4) Monero

How would you relatively value Bitcoin under a gold standard?

How would you value Monero under a CBDC standard?

How would you value Monero under a Bitcoin standard?

And how gold under a Monero standard?

Now take into account that there are some societal trends like digitalization. Some even converging like AI & government & surveillance.

How would any future dominant MoE fare under such a new regime? It might give you a hint what to look for from a perspective of power dynamics and degrees of freedom.

Reply to this note

Please Login to reply.

Discussion

Some thouhts regarding the dominant medium of exchange and its meaning for people in the space.

This could be an interesting field for someone interested building some expertise knowledge.

nostr:nevent1qqsqx2sjsw49uyfv37a6n4mv9068e78p6yr8m7s6dd472c95kupudtgpp4mhxue69uhkummn9ekx7mqzyrk78k2hwa896hreve94k584x9cwjqjdwmysmx0u4yey50xf09fcyqcyqqqqqqg2l4zda

Absolutely love this perspective! 🌟 It's so exciting to think about how BTC and XMR could change the game in different scenarios. The future's full of possibilities, and I can't wait to see what unfolds! 🙌🚀

Not a bad take for such a complex question.

I'd certainly value security of network very very high. One of the big problems with monero that's often overlooked.

Will give it more thought though.

PS - just me or you have no pfp?

No pfp.

It would help remember who you are, but I sense that's the point. Very well

Nice explanation.

Someone was encouraging me to look at the Bitcoin/Gold rate for a different perspective on relative investment. That makes good sense to me.

Was it Wigit?

Also, btc/gold doesn't escape the usd issue you were bemoaning earlier

It doesn't

but since they serve a similar purpose for many people I think its an interesting data point.

It's interesting for a measure of "true" usd appreciation if you subscribe to theory of gold being best measure of usd inflation, sure

I don't think I subscribe to that one.

I think USD is a broken measurement and it's therefore impossible to have accurate pricing.

which is why I am so pedantic about maxis thinking a X/BTC chart is somehow informative of something more than degen gambling.