We are not talking about secrets or private information here. There are other NIPs for that purpose. This is about who has access to what (and why).

Reply to this note

Please Login to reply.

Discussion

exactly. and a paywall fundamentally changes 'who has access and why' from a censorship resistant protocol to a gatekept permissioned one, which simply goes against that principle

That’s why it’s called a NIP. And it’s not part of the “core” protocol (which is NIP-01).

NIP 70 and NIP 68 are pointless possibilities, or useless proposals, whatever you want to call it. for the reason that they don't make sense with the 'core' protocol. get it now?