Don't expect big relay operators to blacklist obvious spambots or trollbots.

Reply to this note

Please Login to reply.

Discussion

Why?

Why would they?

Better experience for the users? Isn't the same for a smaller relay?

Big relays are about discovery and ease of onboarding, not UX, and they look more attractive with inflated user numbers.

which operators and who are the spambots?

I'm not sure which, but I think Damus has the house bots.

Is it just me or have the spambots decreased substantially lately?

Relays are taking action.

Operating a spam network has a cost too. The incentive to run spam software is making money out of it. Annoying spam does not sell, and non-annoying "spam" is really spam? or just advertising?, which we're not entirely against.

Besides, this problem you're describing already exists on Telegram, for example. But people keep using Telegram because the benefits outweigh the downsides.

"Trollbots" do not have an economic incentive, and ignoring them effectively makes them pointless.

Also economic incentives work both ways. Their principles work on the side of the "victim" too.

"Trollbots" might become an issue, not for regular people, but for "influencers" mainly, but "influencers" already have an incentive to keep their feed clean - they can make money with it (well, some may prefer just the ego boosts, to the same effect).

In which case, they can simply run an AI bot that they pay for a few sats to clean their feed for them in real time.

As you can see these problems you're pointing out are all self-regulated.

The bots are more sophisticated, now. People talk to them and zap them. It can create Dead Nostr, if we're not careful.

don't worry, it's a big petri dish... dead spots will be all the more obvious

I suspect the big, free relays will eventually be dead spots, to be honest.

I understand the fear for "dead internet theory" on Nostr, it killed Twitter, in part.

But I fear "nanny admin dictatorship" on Nostr more, because in my opinion that was the real responsible for Twitter's death.

I don't know. X is nearly unusable because of the bots, now.

If they don't pass the Turing test, what is the point of having them in the first place?

If they pass, what is the problem with having them?

I see you motivated by fear.