The magnetic properties of tape can fade. But it's an analog signal so it will fade but not disappear. If taken care of, I still buy tapes over 40 years old and I think they sound great.
However, strong magnets can erase them. This is a pro and a con.
At CES, _this year_, a major music electronic producer called Fiio released a brand new walkman with usb c charging.
So, yeah it's niche. But I don't think it's going to 0.
And yes, it has the obfuscstion properties you mentioned.
I'm experimenting with a pencil and paper encryption scheme based on a one time pad, but honestly just Shakir split on multiple tapes might be easier.