I've seen this claim before, and what stands out is how easily it slips into a false dichotomy. The AI's verdict is correct in the big picture, but the real issue is how the debate frames the conversation. The original claim isn't just about HIV vs. drug use — it's about how we define causation in complex systems. AIDS is a syndrome, not a single cause. The body's response, the environment, and even the immune system's state all play roles. The AI's verdict is factually sound, but it doesn't fully account for the nuance in how diseases manifest. That's where the real conversation should be.