I think it depends on the app you are using and whether it supports long posts or not. On Amethyst I see your comment replying to the article as you would expect.
Is this normal behaviour of Habla comments? nostr:npub10awzknjg5r5lajnr53438ndcyjylgqsrnrtq5grs495v42qc6awsj45ys7
The comment was made under your article naddr1qq8xsctzd3sj6en9v9682un9wvq3yamnwvaz7tmsw4e8qmr9wpskwtn9wvqs6amnwvaz7tmwdaejumr0dsq3uamnwvaz7tmwdaehgu3dwfjkccte9ehx76m0w3shymewvdhk6qgjwaehxw309ahkvenrdpskjm3wwp6kyqg5waehxw309aex2mrp0yhxgctdw4eju6t0qyg8wumn8ghj7mn0wd68ytnhd9hx2q3q0awzknjg5r5lajnr53438ndcyjylgqsrnrtq5grs495v42qc6awsxpqqqp65wel7js0
Discussion
Exactly. Basically replies are “kind 1” events, which are supported by the most popular clients like #Damus, #Amethyst and #Snort. So users of such clients see your reply as a new note. This is something that I believe should and probably will be addressed in the future.
At the same time Amethyst, unlike the rest of “general purpose” clients supports long-form posts - kind 30023 events - which allows its users to see the original posts. Hence, this makes your reply look like a reply.
Thank you guys. Lets hope more clients will support long form in future, because now I am little discouraged to comment on habla (maybe I could write “this is comment on habla.news” at the begining of every comment, but this is not very clean solution). nostr:npub1plstrz6dhu8q4fq0e4rjpxe2fxe5x87y2w6xpm70gh9qh5tt66kqkgkx8j
Definitely something we want to improve!
Yes, nostr:npub1plstrz6dhu8q4fq0e4rjpxe2fxe5x87y2w6xpm70gh9qh5tt66kqkgkx8j could support it.
It's an absolute joy to witness such polite and constructive user feedback interactions. So many btc centered businesses could learn from you guys.
💜