Nostr Web Client

So, now every kind1 needs to render every kind of short note on Nostr? Like all of the chat kinds, issue reply kinds, torrent reply kinds, everything?

You are a product guy. You sure know that just because the technical form is "short" it doesn't mean that users want to see that text everywhere.

Products are designed on the semantics of the message not on the syntax of the data type. This notion that just because posts are short they MUST appear in all kind1 clients doesn't make any sense.

I am sure Olas displays texts notes in the Notifications. You could display it all there. Shouldn't this exact reply appear in your Olas notification?

Maybe you have another tab to see what your friends are doing with all the other kinds?

That's what kind 1 people have done by adding a Replies tab that shows replies from all other kinds. Maybe you should add that tab as well.

Again, it doesn't make any sense.

People don't want to see their Olas replies on Amethyst and vice versa.

HoloKat 10mo ago

Replies and all should stay in the originating client. But new conversations could spawn around the event being surfaced in kind 1 client. It does not need to be rendered in full - which is what I said in my original note.

Reply to this note

Please Login to reply.

Discussion

HoloKat 10mo ago

I’m not saying you couldn’t render it - that’s the client’s choice and how many and what kinds of nips they wish to support

PABLOF7z 10mo ago

I literally keep saying every other note that obviously is not the idea that clients will render all kinds, and even the idea of embedding opengraph data for rich previews as part of NIP-31 is nostr:nprofile1qy88wumn8ghj7mn0wvhxcmmv9uq3qamnwvaz7tmwdaehgu3wd4hk6tcqyprqcf0xst760qet2tglytfay2e3wmvh9asdehpjztkceyh0s5r9cpvx58v (iirc)

Vitor Pamplona 10mo ago

Nostr has over 10 different "short note" kinds and chat kinds today.

And we will have 100s once Nostr becomes big enough.

It will be impossible to render them all just to offer visibility to other clients.

PABLOF7z 10mo ago

By now you must know that that's not what I'm suggesting.

Vitor Pamplona 10mo ago

Sure, but there are multiple ways to do that. People don't need to use kind 1s for everything to get that effect.

HoloKat 10mo ago

I am only talking about having the discovery mechanism - not about any technical implementation.