On another note, I have started watching the TV series ‘Chosen’, very interesting.

Question for those that know the bible ect well, why did Judas betray Jesus?

Reply to this note

Please Login to reply.

Discussion

Greed. Love of money. He turned him in for 30 pieces of silver.

Just for the silver?? Really?

I mean. There were probably other deeper rooted personal issues. But the facts that are there was the betrayed him for the silver.

Wow

Silver used to be used as money.

He did it for money

It has to be done. I don’t want to say more but it’s definitely not for money.

Please do I am very curious friend.

Jesus chose his people wisely. He told his disciples that the person who will betray him would be hated forever. Judas volunteered to be that person.

Silver.

Very strange

Cuz it was meant to be ..

Yes in hindsight, but why did he?

Okay ..you wanna go deep :-)

When God takes a shape .. it must follow the rules of quantum mechanics.. which means all the possibilities..

Since the reality is a mirror image .. #dirac

Every time God manifests .. a perfect mirror image must come into play to complete the mirror .. kind and evil .. grace and deceit .. love and hate .. generous and greed .. they all must go together ..

Interesting, thank you.

Judas really loved silver /god made him do it because God wanted to watch Jesus get crucified

Seems strange though one of his disciples

I believe that Judas was looking for Jesus to set up an earthly kingdom, overthrow Rome, etc, so to usher it in, Judas betrayed Jesus. Judas’ thinking might have been that if Jesus was who He said He was, He wouldn’t be allowed to be crucified and if Jesus wasn’t who He said He was then Jesus wasn’t the messiah anyway. Judas just didn’t understand what Jesus had to do to save mankind (through His death, burial and resurrection). It wasn’t about an earthly kingdom but a spiritual purpose.

Hmmm thank you for this insight, very interesting.

I have really enjoyed The Chosen series. Gives an interesting view of Jesus, the disciples, His followers, etc.

The disciples/followers joked, laughed, couldn’t get along all the time, had conflicts, had struggles, etc.

It’s real life stuff.

Yes exactly, that’s why I’m still watching it.

Wow, any recent interviews of Jesus??

Anything is possible

You never know🤷🏻‍♂️

The AI Grok is wise. I personally think the financial gain was not the real reason. GroK details what other scholars theorize:

Judas Iscariot’s betrayal of Jesus, as described in the New Testament, is a complex and much-debated topic, with various interpretations based on biblical texts, historical context, and theological perspectives. The reasons for his betrayal are not explicitly detailed in a single definitive statement, but several factors are suggested across the Gospel accounts and scholarly interpretations.

Key Reasons and Interpretations:

1. Greed and Financial Motive:

• The Gospels, particularly Matthew 26:14-16 and Mark 14:10-11, state that Judas betrayed Jesus for thirty pieces of silver. This suggests a financial incentive, portraying Judas as motivated by greed or personal gain. In John 12:6, Judas is described as the keeper of the disciples’ money bag and someone who would steal from it, reinforcing the idea of greed as a factor.

2. Disappointment or Ideological Conflict:

• Some scholars propose that Judas may have been disillusioned with Jesus’ mission. Judas might have expected Jesus to be a political or military messiah who would overthrow Roman rule, as many Jews anticipated. Jesus’ focus on spiritual salvation and non-violent teachings (e.g., turning the other cheek, loving enemies) may have clashed with Judas’ expectations, leading him to betray Jesus out of frustration or to force Jesus’ hand to act decisively.

3. Theological or Predestined Role:

• In some interpretations, Judas’ betrayal is seen as part of a divine plan. In John 13:27, it’s noted that “Satan entered into Judas” before the betrayal, suggesting spiritual influence or possession. Additionally, Jesus predicts the betrayal (e.g., John 13:21-26, Matthew 26:21-25), implying it was foreordained. Some theologians argue Judas was an instrument in fulfilling prophecy (e.g., Psalm 41:9, cited in John 13:18), though this raises questions about free will versus destiny.

4. Personal Resentment or Envy:

• Judas may have felt marginalized or envious within the group of disciples. For instance, his role as treasurer (John 12:6) might have isolated him, or he may have resented Jesus’ growing emphasis on other disciples, like Peter or John. This is speculative but often explored in psychological analyses of his character.

5. External Pressures or Fear:

• Judas might have acted under pressure from the religious authorities (e.g., the Sanhedrin), who sought to arrest Jesus discreetly to avoid a public uproar (Luke 22:2-6). Fear of consequences or a desire to align with powerful figures could have influenced his decision.

6. Moral or Spiritual Failure:

• The Gospels depict Judas as succumbing to moral weakness or spiritual corruption. In Luke 22:3 and John 13:2, Satan’s influence is explicitly mentioned, suggesting Judas was vulnerable to temptation or lacked the faith to resist. His later remorse (Matthew 27:3-5), where he returns the money and hangs himself, indicates regret but not necessarily repentance.

Additional Context:

• Historical Context: The socio-political climate of first-century Judea, under Roman occupation, was tense. Many Jews, including possibly Judas, hoped for a messiah to liberate them. Jesus’ refusal to fit this mold might have created tension among his followers.

• Textual Variations: The Gospels differ slightly in their portrayal. Matthew emphasizes the money, John highlights Satan’s role, and Luke suggests a combination of spiritual and opportunistic motives. The non-canonical Gospel of Judas (a 2nd-century Gnostic text) portrays Judas as fulfilling a divine role at Jesus’ request, though this is not accepted in mainstream Christianity.

• Cultural Interpretations: Over centuries, Judas has been depicted as a villain, a tragic figure, or even a misunderstood agent of God’s will. His motives remain ambiguous, inviting diverse theological and literary interpretations.

Why It’s Complex:

The Bible does not provide a definitive psychological profile of Judas, leaving room for interpretation. His actions could stem from a mix of personal, spiritual, and external factors. The lack of clarity ensures ongoing debate among theologians, historians, and scholars.

If you’d like, I can dive deeper into a specific Gospel account, explore theological perspectives, or analyze cultural depictions of Judas (e.g., in art or literature). Let me know!

Thanks Frank, this will take some time for me to go through but very, very interesting 🙏

Every reference on every platform regarding religion. Makes me fear when we tear the money control stick from the powers that be, they'll reignite religion as a way to brutally control humanity.. Its certainly happened before!

And more than likely happen again.

Judas believed the messiah would be more of a warrior that would over throw Rome and not sacrifice himself for our salvation.

Thank you

- Satan entered his heart (Lk. 22.3)

- he wanted Jesus to be a political Messiah, throw off Rome, and take the earthly throne

- for the silver

- he wanted 'his best life NOW'

Thank you for your thoughts