Nostr Web Client

There are very few examples from which to draw that statement. Socialism is not great. It is state controlled. All examples of communism (though maybe improperly referred to as communism) that are used for propaganda were state/fascist controlled. Revolutionary Catalonia is one of the few large examples of anarcho-communism. The two philosophies are not contradictory. I have been a part of many anarchistic/ anarcho communistic oriented happenings and they are fantastic, and fair. Anarcho-communism abolishes the state and removes any hierarchical structures. The company Tesla for example, would be owned by the people, no single person. The positive implications this has for society are inumerable.

sms 10mo ago 💬 2

For a short time, on individual or small group scale, sure can exist, the way subatomic particles exist in an atom collider for a moment.

Most individual interactions among us are anarchic and some are even communist.

On any larger scale, the local thug gangs that only want and know how to do violent, coercive activities, quickly figure out that they can own the local communes as their personal Animal Farm and live by milking them as parasites, simply by declaring themselves "government".

Under pretext of providing "protection" ( first of all FROM THEMSELVES) compensated through "taxes", for local, productive, peaceful, voluntary communes, was how practically all #state #government emerged, and always would under anarcho- communism model.

Humans are predators, even among ourselves!

Reply to this note

Please Login to reply.

Discussion

Jacob 10mo ago

this is not true. ignorance is predatory, humans are not. ignorance is also weak. what you described currently exists as "fruit" (inedible) of modern democracy. there has never been a large scale example of anarcho communism. we have never until now had the means of communication to achieve such. power is in community, and it only harms the "ill willed" to harm anyone else. the collective and individuals are perfectly able to defend themselves, if that ill presented. the saying goes: do no harm, but take no shit.

sms 10mo ago 💬 1

What you describe is wishful thinking.

Long before anything that could be called "democracy", armed gangs declared themselves " government " over large territories, effectively enslaving the local population to exploit it, simply because it was a viable way to make a rather plush living.

That's the reason neither anarcho-communism nor even proper communism has ever existed anywhere at scale.

Jacob 10mo ago

what you described, is 100% what we currently have going on right now.