I'm running gossip and Amethyst in parallel at the moment. I really recommend you to have this experience on your own.
That's what I'm doing currently:
* My main focus is on gossip and my mobile is within reach running in the notifications tab.
a) When my focus is on gossip, I feel that I am really able to contribute good content/ notes and interactions.
b) When I look down to my mobile I feel distracted by thoughs like "oh, who is this npub which liked one of my notes and I don't follow yet." I click on this profile and get a feeling of getting lost in nostr. This usage type might be good for discovering the network.
Probably both is needed and the devices mobile + full keyboard are not comparable to each other. However my point is not to outdo one client against another or one end user device against another, but to have a possibilty to reflect ones own behaviour on nostr by using different clients WITH DIFFERENT NOTIFICATIONS CONCEPTS.