Of course it's taxable. It's income.
Discussion
Right, but if I'm a coffee shop owner, I don't have to calculate FIFO/LIFO for the cost basis for every transaction with fiat.
Technically I do if it's crypto. Customer pays for coffee using Bitcoin on a Tuesday, price is $82k. Now I want to convert that to fiat on a Saturday, price is now $85k. I'm now legally required to account for capital gains on that $3.00 transaction.