I think he's alright, he's in his 40's and looks about what you would expect. The hair thing he had done has certainly helped a lot.

Plus as you point out there is a lot more to attraction that just the man's looks. It's fine to dream over him dude, I'm sure most of the women who swear they wouldn't go near him are only saying this because they don't think they would ever meet him in person. Hating him is a much more acceptable take.