Blue no longer supports custodial Lightning (unless they’ve picked it back up)

Phoenix is reliable with plenty of features, rarely have issues, but support is email only

Mutiny I’m still getting used to but super clean UX, team is cool

Aqua can be confusing at first (it displays Lightning and liquid as a single balance and - I believe - swaps Lightning receives into Lbtc within the wallet), but it seems to work well

Zeus is really nice, with a ton of versatility, but sometimes UX seems like it’s built for Lightning pros and not the average user. Super responsive “support team” (ie Evan is very on top of his shit)