People might now be aware of this, but nostr is such an easy target for personalised ads and big data. While the web struggles to establish static identifiers and user profiles, nostr has all of it built in. Your identifier is your pubkey. Your profile data already is publicly available. It is a piece of cake for an advertiser to serve targeted ads to you, just by knowing your public key.

Here is a simplified example: I could go ahead and analyse relay traffic, then proceed to build a database that maps pubkeys to interest and demographics (for example by running all your notes through an LLM). Then I could go to any advertiser and tell them that I can offer them an audience „Male 21-35 yo, interested in tech and steaks“. Display campaigns with similar targets yield 3-6$ CPM on the traditional web.

Finally I would approach Will (who would surely decline, but just for the sake of this example) and tell him that he could earn 200$ per day be simply requesting a display ad from my server every ten posts on Damus feed. All he needed to do is to implement my SDK and send the users public key with the request…

This gets even worse on the web, because JavaScript and cookies…

This is a dystopia that might become reality if client developers can not find a less shitty way to monetise… nostr:note1ltskvvkn4avertvjlpyrw5jhcc9jgwxxx5cfpkrnr7kd99z7kh0s09rtec

Reply to this note

Please Login to reply.

Discussion

Nostr’s “weakness” that everything is “public” is also its superpower.

The more a commodity is freely and openly available, the less value it has for exploitation in the market.

User data and user attention are the TWO commodities in play here. Simply by assuring open access and freedom of choice for the users in both of these domains, Nostr has (potential) to eliminate this market for ad revenue.

Because clients hold the power to “implement” content filters of their choosing, without consent from end users, the marketing of user attention is still a vulnerability for Nostr.

“Sovereign Webs of Trust” (where users have domain over who “is trusted” and what “filters” to implement across clients) is the solution.

What would this look like for you?

nostr:note1q2a2stds7ndxe9h9xz82u20szgur0yyp2gmdkz853dvdvl66stqsgj6awd

A less shitty way to monetize … will be the market that opens up when users subscribe to and share their best “Sovereign WoT” filters.

The money is in content discovery. Algos are not the problem. Freedom of choice is the solution.