I think you missed the part where I said Bills don't give rights. It protects them. We should want them. Regardless of they "work" or not. We should advocate for the society we want.
Discussion
Yah. Rights not real.
If its a right how can it be granted?
How can it be requested?
If it a right then it is inalienable
Otherwise its just the grace of the rulers at play. Permissions not rights.