I want the perpetrator(s) to repent and then to be executed. I am making the point that if the perpetrator repents he must be forgiven. And I am making the point that forgiveness of sin does not absolve a man from facing earthly justice, so he should also be executed for his crime.
If Tyler is innocent, he should not be executed. Right now with the evidence and information I have seen, and taking into account content I have seen online from people who are proposing counter narratives, Tyler appears to me to be the perpetrator. I am not convinced, however, that he acted alone. I also recognize that there are things that don't make sense yet or don't add up yet, like the supposed text thread. But there are other ways to make sense of things like that ridiculous text thread than to come to the conclusion that Tyler did not pull the trigger.
Once again, my larger point is about the nature of mercy and justice.