I didn't say that relay server coders can't code -- the servers are impressive in what they've achieved. What I've said is I'm surprised at how little spam filtering appears to have been built into the servers from the start (though I caveated that with the fact that I have not reviewed the codebases).

I've also said that it's an arms race. That if teams of engineers with massive resources at the likes of Twitter can't stop spam the best solution is paid relays. I stand by that, though I do apologize if I've sounded overly harsh in my criticism. The spam situation has indeed been very frustrating for everyone, myself included.

As for how to attract newbies without free relays, how does any product attract new customers without giving it away for free? It offers what other products can't, and at a price that people are willing to pay. Nostr offers freedom of expression and an algo-free experience.

Spam-filled feeds certainly won't attract newbies. One quick browse through the Global feed in most apps and a lot of people will likely walk away saying Nostr is just a spam farm full of telegram invites and porn. Maybe there's a hybrid solution. That's what I'm trying to achieve with NostrGram.

Reply to this note

Please Login to reply.

Discussion

People expect free when they are told to, and expect to pay when told that.

Nostr will grow organically by friends bringing friends, walleting them up, introducing the ease and power of small micropayments and in effect sidestepping Global.

I'm not too concerned.

I also expect spam killing to get better. A script that auto publishes spam npubs to all the relays, that then parse it and if that npub joins (take their money, why not), then blocks their write.

I agree Nostr will grow through grassroots friends-and-family adoption. That's one of the things that makes it great imo.

All the paid relays I joined and added on astral and snort now show up on Nostrgram in paid relays. This is like magic :-)