Are expiring posts technically feasible on nostr?

Reply to this note

Please Login to reply.

Discussion

No

👎

I think there’s an expiring tag

What do you mean?

Technically yes, but you have to trust the both relays and clients correctly erase the post after the expiration.

Thank you.

If both client and relay servers run open source code that you've verified has this functionality, what is there to trust?

That everyone that received the event is also using a client and relay that support it. It's not about your app and your relays. It's about everybody else's.

So does the same thing go for burn after reading? Ie if you self host the relay, then you trust the relay, but isn't the client trust problem the same problem as someone can even shot your Snapchat?

Anything is possible but question is whether relays honor expiration. This can be remedied through UI and UX. But people who don’t think in UX terms just throw their hands up and say “on the internet everything is forever” or “my relay will save it “ or “screenshot, idiot!!!”

If it's important that your note truly expires for privacy or safety reasons, you need to assume it won't, for the reasons you mentioned

Or this ..

‘Thinking in UX terms’ isn’t exactly a nostr strength. 😬

I didn't know this was a thing.

I didn't know they expired..

Digital information decays pretty fast .. expiry is inbuilt in the nature ..

The harder part is to make it unexpirable .. that is why #bitcoin is so precious..