Once they repent, is it proper to kill them? Serious question.

God was clear about animals that kill humans: from their life will the blood be repaid. The same for humans.

But I'm happy to concede on the grounds of mercy.

But there is something else: deterrent. Consider the phrase "the only thing they understand is force". There are people that would consider committing evil if it were not for the consequences.

The consequences need to be there. The laws need teeth.

I might even suggest it would be good if the execution were public / leaked.

Reply to this note

Please Login to reply.

Discussion

The biggest deterrent is the chance of getting caught and the likelihood of successful prosecution.

I think capital punishment is favored, in the USA, because normal punishments are already so draconian that you have to "top" them, for particularly heinous crimes. We don't have that issue here, as we don't have such long sentences, so life in prison is how we "top".

What is proper about killing anyone? Makes it sound like it's a polite habit, like chewing food with your mouth closed.

I am of the opinion that we should avoid killing ourselves or others, whether intentionally or by accident. The Church doesn't condemn capital punishment as evil, but it's definitely something we should tend to prefer the alternatives to, wherever possible and practical.