Playing D&D, if you cast Holy Water on water that freezes, then you put the ice cube in a glass of water, does the rest of the water become holy also?
#D&Dquestions
Discussion
I don't know enough to say, but I'd like to know also. I'm going to start playing with my kids soon.
General consensus on twit is in D&D 5e it does not. To create holy water, a cleric or paladin spend 1 hour, 25 sp of silver, and a 1 st level spell slot to make a flask of 1 lb of water, holy water. This will only harm fiends and undead with 2d6 radiant damage.
as a note, Sacred Flame is a cantrip with no limit on casting and does 1d6 radiant damage Dex save.
the advantage is anyone can throw the flask as an improvised weapon and no save.
In Pathfinder 2e it is a vial and can only be made in a temple of a Good god, at 3 gp a vial, does 1d6 good damage, thrown 20', when combined with Holy Cascade (4th lv spell) causes the vial to burst 20' doing 3d6 good damage.
Awesome thanks, this should be fun.