In my eyes, the biggest draw of Nostr has never been censorship resistence. It has always been possible to shrug off censorship from the very moment that the first microblogging platform was launched. Simply by switching to plain old blogging. Run your own relay? Nah dude, just run your own Wordpress site.

The true advantage of microblogging and Nostr is the promise to the user: that the user themselves can choose what content is filtered for them or not. And that the user themselves can figure out exactly what content they aren't seeing. Microblogging exists because the user shouldn't have to run their own damn web-spider just to be able to have their best possible content feed.

However, I believe that Nostr has not yet fulfilled this promise. What does a new user see the moment they make a Nostr account? They see a list of relays, but every single relay looks exactly the same. It isn't possible to determine what their policy is for storing notes because the protocol isn't designed with that in mind.

But look at Mastadon and Activity Pub, and you'll be able to see EXACTLY what an instance is about. You can scroll through the list of blocked instances, or often, a list of individual moderator decisions. Nostr has no equivalent and it's devastating.

This isn't about the ability to post or to read, it's about the ability to connect with the people you want to, even if you had no idea they would be there.

Reply to this note

Please Login to reply.

Discussion

Thanks man really well written idea... So tldr you like WordPress Microblog activitypub and stuff better then--- nostr rn...... but you think nostr has potential for connecting with different ppl so you stick around???

TL;DR: if you care about censorship, but don't care about personal effort or about making things easy for your potential followers then Wordpress is a great option.

If you care about personal effort or about making things easy for your potential followers then services built on ActivityPub (such as Mastadon) are great options.

If you care about censorship and personal effort, but don't care about making things easy for potential followers, then Nostr is a good protocol without any more updates to the protocol or clients.

But if you care about censorship AND about making things easy for potential followers then Nostr is only slightly better than the alternatives in its current state, no matter how much effort you are willing to go to.

In it's current state, Nostr's users will never be able to tell when that censorship exists, or which relays they have to add to bypass it, but at least it's easy if you ever find out.

Wow greatful for you taking the time to help me understand with a simple breakdown of the landscape comparing all the relative differences.