I disagree, I think that defeats the purpose of nostr and what it originally stands for.
If there is a major news highlighting content from amethyst, users all have to login to view via amethyst aka centralisation.
I don’t care who is fighting with who but as a user, I should not be forced to used a client to engage with other users. On Nostr
If a user decides to remain private then it’s the users choice
If a client prohibits users from Nostr from viewing their users, then it should be relabelled as some thing else - private client etc.
We want to move away from centralisation. This impact is way worse