Pornography and and Christian Libertarian Worldview

Yesterday I witnesses several plebs standing up for and applauding sex workers once the dust settled from the zapathon. Controversy was due to the fact that one of these ladies used the #zapathon tag to show off her "assets" to plebs during this highly anticipated and high traffic time. I witnessed the same pictures everyone else did and was initially offended that someone would use that hashtag for marketing x-rated material that could be witnessed by anyone who didn't Agree to the infamous cheeto stick guard rail 18+ content warnings. And yet, I'm on Nostr to help support in anyway I can to promote freedom from government overreach. As a Christian who understands and says he believes in libertarian principles, this posed a problem for me.

For all the non-Christians on Nostr, I totally get why this freedom is encouraged and applauded, but for Christians, how are we to look at this situation?

Christians hold to the idea that morality is not subjectively based on what we believe is right or wrong. This would be to make a God in our own image that is conveniently accepting of all our sins. Instead, we believe that God has set in place an objective moral standard, and this is the standard in which we will be judged by when we meet our Maker. This worldview frames how we view everything else in life, even our political inclinations.

In regards to the issue of pornography, the power of decentralization has given this work unlimited freedom. At this point, it is unstoppable and comical to assume that it could be. And yet, we inherently know that these freedoms can and will be abused, and ultimately lead to higher levels of protected perversions such as child pornography, rape, pedophilia, etc. Our political inclinations prevent us from running to the government for help. This decentralized technology has already left the harbor. Instead, the only means of escaping this is to purpose to do so individually, to be in the world but not of the world.

I for one, cannot applaud in good conscience the existence or inevitable growth of sex work on decentralized platforms any more than I can applaud those who will use it to sell drugs that will kill people, traffic women, or coordinate assassinations. Varying degrees of morality, granted, but consider the effects. A girl on onlyfans is ignorant of the ramifications of her influence on her clients conscience and actions. What might be a means of paying rent for her is a stain on the conscience of the man who willingly took advantage of her marketing. What starts off as vanilla, sporatic self-gratification will grow into an obsessive addiction that will continually seek darker perversions. Granted, the man is morally responsible for his own actions, and God will hold him accountable for every word, thought, and action. However, God warns that those who cause others to sin will be judged greatly. Thus, out of love for these women, I cannot applaud, but must mourn that these women are digging themselves their own grave.

So what is a #Christian to do? We don't judge those who are outside the Church of Christ, considering we are in no conceivable way morally superior. We do, however, encourage everyone to find freedom, true freedom, in the hope and service of Christ. He offers a freedom that Nostr and #Bitcoin can't provide us, and that is the freedom of knowing that although our sins are horrendous, Christ offers forgiveness to even the worst offenders. He offers freedom of conscience that allows the Christian to wake up every morning free from the burden of a fractured conscience, even though he knows he will inevitably mess up today. We have a benevolent King and Savior who cares for and comforts the shamed and broken hearted sex worker who hates herself for what she does.

As a Christian who believes in freedom, I seek a world, here and now, that is free of all evils, including the evil that rests in each of our hearts. Decentralization will disrupt how the world operates, and Christians need to understand the implications and effects this will have on society. But rather than pouting about how sinners shouldn't be allowed to sin, it forces us to realize that Christianity isn't about depending on the government to save us, but striving for holiness and allowing Christ to work in our hearts so that we no longer chase corruption.

I've heard that there are means in which one can build a relay that blocks unwanted content. I'm not familiar enough with the technology yet, and how we'd go about doing that. However, as a call to action to those who do not share my worldview and convictions, consider the fact that a platform that is free and safe for even children to use is much more appealing to masses seeking the freedom we can offer them than a platform that celebrates freedom FOR sinful use. In 10 years, #Nostr could be a hub for brilliant minds and sciences unadulterated by political propaganda or it could be reduced to the most depraved and unfiltered version of the Darkweb. We have the opportunity to choose today what tomorrow will look like. If that means factions of differing worldviews form and divide the work being done here, realize it is a feature of freedom, not a bug.

Reply to this note

Please Login to reply.

Discussion

This post reads as very judgy. Can’t you just stay out of global? Or don’t most clients blur all pics from people you don’t follow?

Not a problem. Christians or other restrictive or sensible religions can have their own "clean" relays with their own desired content. That's the beauty.

Or you can just block people that offend you :).

This seems a bit one-sided to me. I think shifting all the responsibility onto those who do not want to see the content isn't the way to go.

Running your own clean relay is probably unrealistic for people who aren't super techy, and becomes something that is either quarantined away, or has to be constantly curated.

Blocking anyone who posts something you don't like is a tiring task, and seems silly.

I like onyx vixen's clean posts, but I don't want to see her naked. The nsfw filter on Amethyst makes this work, and she is pretty respectful in using it.

I think respect is what it comes down to. Nostr is new, and people are bumping into the boundaries through exploration. A sense of propriety will evolve naturally. Sex workers will come to understand that they should label nsfw content as such. There will always be exceptions, but that is much easier to account for.

How does one run a 'clean' relay? I find little info on how relays can be managed in this way.

You can only allow access to it to a specific set of keys i suppose.

Well said.

You touch on many things I've had on my mind, here. But, rampant porn addiction among men and boys, and the affects on them and their relationships is key among them.

This doesn't even have to reference religion. Men and boys are suffering, being hollowed out. Sex workers have no idea or don't care.

I find it hard to ignore the parallels of a drug dealer selling the addict another hit.

I only hope that, someday, sooner than later, the data will become available and widely acknowledged. And, sex workers will realize the damage they do, and turn to a different path.

Great thread, one massive problem.

It’s like 7 pages long.

Break this down into bite sized pieces.

No one has the attention span for this.

Blessed.

⚡️

Pornography is certainly a blight on our culture, and something that enslaves the souls of many men and women alike.

Thankfully, most Nostr clients have ways for those of us who want to avoid it to keep it out of our feeds.

That said, the beauty of nostr is that NO speech can be censored. While this allows for pornographic material to be freely posted, it also ensures that Christians can proclaim the gospel in the digital public square without fear of being silenced.

Freedom technology always cuts both ways. Just like the Roman roads of the ancient world that allowed greater freedom of movement for slave traders and gospel ministers alike, Nostr will be utilized both for and against the promotion of debauchery.

I, for one, will celebrate the censorship resistance we have here, even if it means things that I believe are sinful are actively promoted here, because it also means that redemption, forgiveness, and Christ's imputed righteousness can be freely promoted without hindrance.

I agree with you that pornography and prostitution are bad. The problem on Nostr is similar to the problem on the web, and filtering solutions can be used in either case to protect children and others who don't want exposure. The Nostr protocol architecture allows for customized solutions to restrict content for particular users. This can be done in the client, in relays, or in caching services such as what Primal has. I recommend this Citadel Dispatch video on Nostr and Primal because they get into some of this.

https://www.youtube.com/live/NEuW7_mUIdM?feature=share

The deeper problem with this stuff is the culture's move away from a Christian worldview and the growing belief that free sexual expression is healthy and doesn't hurt anyone. In some ways, this is starting to reverse as casualties of the sexual revolution continue to mount up over time. However, it is difficult for someone with a naturalistic worldview to put together a consistent sexual ethic that solves all of these problems. It is only in the context of God's loving plan for the human family and the means of salvation that he provides that sexual morality makes any sense. So I don't think there is any real solution apart from the Christian Gospel and conversion. Alongside the Gospel, understanding the problems of the sexual revolution are helpful in understanding that God's ways are not arbitrary restrictions of a kill-joy, but are meant for human flourishing.

God gave us free will, how much love would be be displaying to God if we had no other choice but to choose him. The nature of freedom it implies evil will exist. A choice without an option is not a choice. Choose the good, do not wish there was no choice. If there are externalities i.e. child phonography we would have duty to protect the innocent from predators.