Replying to Avatar waxwing

My best guess about their logic, assuming they didn't just completely misunderstand the systems, is this:

With a chaumian blinding server, you have a situation where none of the N participants know the linkages, and nor does the server. So from a privacy perspective this is decentralized, no one actor is privileged.

However even if you look at it as an academic and not a practicioner, you should see that having a central server coordinating the transaction is a very important centralization, because they can select, and control, which participants are allowed to be in what join event. (*very* relevant for e.g. sybil concerns).

So in short I agree with your question 😄

Avatar
fiatjaf 2y ago

Maybe the concern would be solved if they had said something about chaumian blinding and not about "decentralization". I would say that by any human definition of "decentralization" JoinMarket is at least more decentralized than the other two.

But I think I will settle for them completely misunderstanding everything.

Reply to this note

Please Login to reply.

Discussion

No replies yet.