I've been living in many different parts of Zomia for about 20 years now. I've read James C. Scott and I think there's a slight romanticism in his work.

Zomia, I think, extends into southern central Chinese provinces like Hunan, birthplace of Chairman Mao, albeit in surrounding mountainous regions. I've been in Miao villages there that are seriously hard to get to. Rammed earth houses that are falling apart. Kilns no longer used. Terraces planted out to timber trees because it's cheaper for them to just buy rice. They just want their children to go to university.

In many parts of Laos and northern Thailand, you very rarely see police. There are village chiefs. They like to settle things on their own. And it works. But still, not so many young people.

Reply to this note

Please Login to reply.

Discussion

Well, Scott says that with advent of modern nation state, things have changed (and thus probably not many young people). That's why we have cryptoanarchy, because as attack vectors changed, so have to change the defense tactics.

Anyway very cool you've lived there, I would be excited to hear more about it. I've been to quite a few of these myself (Yunnan / Xishuangbanna, Laos, Cambodia, northern Thailand), it's fascinating, especially if you consider the terrain and the fact that people really used to live there 😉 .

I enjoyed also his other books (Seeing like the State, Against the Grain).

True. I'm actually in Yunnan now. Gorgeous place.