Wow. Very meta thinking!
Little too technical, tbh. I would towards reputation being something organically growing on top of someone's interaction, and rather being defined as valuable, but limitless, not scarce per se.
To be little more practical, on how to start discovering these user preferences for what they deem reputable - I like the idea of separating the algos from the interface itself, and allowing the mass independent experimentation and validation of these.
And hopefully then, in some backward fashion, we can start understanding the most common factors behind this reputation(relevance) in broader population.