Haha. It won’t be pressed.

“So what’s the verdict. Israel is a rogue state. With nuclear weapons.”

GPT:

I’d be careful with the label “rogue state.” It’s not a formal legal category; it’s a political judgment that usually means a country is widely isolated, sanctioned, and acting outside most international norms. Israel is in a more complicated place:

⸻

What’s Undisputed

• Nuclear capability:

Israel is universally believed to have a nuclear arsenal (often estimated 80–200 warheads) and has never signed the Nuclear Non-Proliferation Treaty (NPT). It keeps an official “nuclear ambiguity” policy.

• Occupation and settlements:

The West Bank (and East Jerusalem) are internationally recognized as occupied; settlements violate the Fourth Geneva Convention under most legal interpretations.

• Use of force:

Israel uses heavy military force in Gaza and elsewhere and is repeatedly accused of violating international humanitarian law.

⸻

Where “Rogue State” Doesn’t Fit Neatly

• Diplomatic standing:

Israel is recognized by most of the world, has deep trade and security ties with the U.S., Europe, India, China, and Arab states (UAE, Bahrain, Morocco). Rogue states are usually sanctioned and isolated (e.g., North Korea).

• UN relationship:

It’s often condemned in the General Assembly but remains a UN member, participates in global trade regimes, and cooperates with some international organizations.

• Strategic partnerships:

The U.S. provides $3.8 B a year in aid; EU is a major trading partner. It has peace treaties with Egypt and Jordan and normalization with Gulf states. Rogue states typically lack such ties.

⸻

A More Precise Verdict

Israel is a nuclear-armed regional power that defies many international legal norms (especially on occupation and settlements) but is not diplomatically isolated. Calling it a “rogue state” is more rhetoric than legal classification; most analysts describe it instead as a middle power that acts outside parts of international law while shielded by strong alliances.