There is some merit to this, doctors - at least of the kind described, YMMV depending on where you live and what doctor you go to - certainly aren't interested in finding these kinds of causes, but be aware that things can go too far in the other direction too. To take a rather extreme example, if you take this approach too far, especially confrontationally, to someone who is seriously depressed, you may very well be the straw that breaks the camels back, and they end up killing themself instead.

Regarding the article in question, there are plenty physical ailments that show up as fatigue etc. and are not helped by sleep, food and exercise, but should of course not just be masked by pills either. OP seems to take it for granted that the girlfriends problems are the result of something she's doing or not doing. That may be the case, but it might also not be. Doctor should investigate these possibilities too.

Reply to this note

Please Login to reply.

Discussion

I don't take it for granted that the problems she has are the result of something she is doing or not doing. I'm just very shocked that the doctor never asked her if she is doing something or not doing it. The fact that you leave out most of reality in your diagnosis as a doctor is truly terrifying me. As I said, I'm not a doctor, and I don't have a clue about anything honestly. But this feels like very bad practice!

I don't want to go to my mechanic when my car is dead and he is not even looking at my car and tells me how he can fix it

OK, then I misunderstood the gist of the post. I still think we agree, that the doctor didn't check for causes, either internal or external, but just prescribed pills for the symptoms. I'm thinking such things are likely to cause worse problems in the future, since the root cause isn't dealt with, whatever it is.

To continue with the car analogy, it would be like the engine making strange noises and the mechanic tells you to turn the radio up so that you don't hear it. That's not likely to end well...

Exactly! That's what bothers me