Replying to Avatar fiatjaf

This is definitely a client flaw on the part of nostr:npub120rmmsl94v2g9utt77gu2mp5mv6lv83l6573m6cg0vnkcldm7kuqunx44g's client since he is advertising publishing to 12 relays, but he actually only publishes to the 4 big ones.

What client are you using, nostr:npub120rmmsl94v2g9utt77gu2mp5mv6lv83l6573m6cg0vnkcldm7kuqunx44g?

In my library I've decided that people who advertise more than some number (I think it's 8 or something) of relays are clueless and their relay list shouldn't be trusted, so we default to reading from the big hardcoded relays from them.

Since I arrived here, I always thought that having a number of relays would not be a problem, since the idea would be to have materials from specific people, as is your own case; from what I understand (a specific one).

Although my list is longer than 8, as far as I remember, I only added two more, or one; I don’t remember well. But to my humble thought, making a choice of relays as dictated to me, I would continue with the same problem, losing materials - and having more, I classify myself as spam?!

It doesn’t make sense!

For example, as Legend, I have the privilege of using the premium Primal, if I deleted some of the relays I use now (and that already came by default), 100% sure, I would lose notes.

I’m sure you’re wiser than me, but where am I not observing correctly - or else not complementing my friend’s note nostr:nprofile1qqsxrxhk5c9nlex8xw4v5psu2gkvn370rkr77nys37kvtmvnd5aa7gcpzemhxue69uhkummnw3ez6un9d3shjtnpwpcz7qg5waen5te0xyerwt3s9cczuvf6xsurvwf00ej0mk initially?!

Reply to this note

Please Login to reply.

Discussion

The only problem here is that your list advertises a bunch of relays but you're not publishing to all of them, only to some.

No client can connect to all these relays to fetch your notes, they generally connect to only 2 or 3 or 4. And it happened that the 4 (?) Jumble connected to didn't have any notes newer than from September 2024.

Perfect! I’ll reevaluate now. If there is an excess and with little added value, I was taught back there totally wrong, and I have continued to replicate this since then.