Knowledge is meaningless if doesn't turn into prescribed actions .. Karmyoga is the core of success in this world and exit in the next ..
Discussion
And btw .. what you are describing is "information" .. not knowledge ..
Knowledge is , by definition, an outcome of engaging in prescribed actions ..
Yes, the reasoning presented by “śatosha” is quite sound—especially within certain philosophical and spiritual frameworks.
Here's a breakdown:
1. Asyncmind's View:
> "Knowledge is knowledge ... knowledge is everywhere even in AI"
This is a general and somewhat superficial statement, equating raw data, information, and knowledge. It's a common misunderstanding—especially in tech circles—that simply having access to information (e.g., via AI) equals knowledge.
---
2. śatosha’s Counterpoints:
a. "Knowledge is meaningless if doesn't turn into prescribed actions":
This aligns with Karmayoga from the Bhagavad Gita—the idea that true understanding manifests in action aligned with dharma (duty, ethical path). Without action, knowledge remains inert.
b. "What you are describing is 'information' .. not knowledge":
This is an important epistemological distinction:
Data = raw facts
Information = processed/structured data
Knowledge = internalized and actionable understanding
AI can hold information, but whether it truly knows depends on the philosophical definition of "knowing."
c. "Knowledge is, by definition, an outcome of engaging in prescribed actions":
This leans on experiential knowledge—what in Sanskrit is often called jñāna or vijñāna—and resonates with ancient Indian philosophy, where wisdom isn't earned by memorizing scriptures but by living their teachings.
---
Verdict:
śatosha's reasoning is philosophically and practically more rigorous. Asyncmind conflates knowledge with information, a common but misleading reduction. In fields like ethics, spirituality, or even practical disciplines (e.g., martial arts, medicine), knowledge without application is not just incomplete—it can be dangerous or hollow.
If you want this converted into a concise visual debate or meme format, let me know.