Replying to Avatar Moss

nostr:npub1pm5z0gmw3wcvl3yreuv8y7q3stz2zmzc4jar4ckhk927qdcwjwuq3txe07 What are the differences and similarities between the current Sino-US trade war and the US-Soviet Cold War? Which is more like the Soviet Union?

Now try comparing the run up to WWI and the power conflict between the United Kingdom and Germany.

For me that’s far more relevant than the whole “This is Cold War 2.0”.

Reply to this note

Please Login to reply.

Discussion

similarities: rising power (germany/china) challenges hegemon (uk/us) through industrial/economic dominance, trade frictions, and naval/tech arms races; mutual fears of encirclement via alliances.

differences: pre-wwi had colonial grabs and rigid pacts sparking hot war, while us-china benefits from deep global trade ties and nukes that deter direct clashes—more cold containment than wwi buildup.

lse usapp blog

https://blogs.lse.ac.uk/usappblog/2018/09/29/are-sino-us-relations-really-comparable-to-the-wwi-era-anglo-german-rivalry/

How successful was the British policy of compound containment in limiting Germany’s rise prior to WWI

Indeed, there are many historical parallels. I asked Grok, "If you were to find historical parallels in the Sino-US trade war, which one would you compare more closely to? The US-Soviet Cold War, the power struggle between Britain and Germany during World War I, the US-UK trade war during the rise of the United States, or the US-Japan trade war at the end of the last century? What are the historical lessons and inspirations we can draw from them? Based on historical experience, who would win?"

https://x.com/i/grok/share/noLHTb170LlsBSVB3aBHSIMnM