Nostr Web Client

Hey I'm sorry to hear you're back to malicious spamming. Tor is not special, it's a centralized team that picks who is allowed to remain a node. Tor hides what IP you're coming from the website owner, while Arweave does not even notify the owner.

I am unwilling to read your malicious spam, please actually read the content before mouthing off.

Scoundrel 2mo ago 💬 2

Is any part of my post addressed by your own? You insist that there is something vitally important which I didn't read, but apparently it wasn't worth it for you to even so much as copy and paste it onto Nostr? I wrote out a response specially for your note responding to some of the things you said. Does that sound like low effort spamming to you?

You are right that Tor's team of independent directory authorities vote on what nodes get excluded from the network, but that doesn't contradict what I said about Tor. For the users, Tor provides decentralized trust.

Is Arweave a cryptocurrency? A darknet? What is the threat model? Y'all compare yourself with Tor, but I need someone to walk me through this.

Reply to this note

Please Login to reply.

Discussion

SimplifiedPrivacy.com 2mo ago

An IP address is a physical location. This is true for where packets come from, like a VPN. And it's true for hosting sites, like a Tor Onion. Tor hides this. It hides where the guy comes from, and it hides server locations where hosted with an onion.

Arweave is a new way to do the internet, a parallel society where physical locations are less relevant, because all content is everywhere. Things aren't addressed as going to an IP or hosted on an IP, but instead by the content.

The purpose of this is similar to Nostr. It can do nearly any type of activity the internet can do. And as far as threat model, it's not designed for drugs/illegal the same way Tor is. In this case, advocating for using for videos, blogs, podcasts.

Scoundrel 2mo ago 💬 3

I don't understand your platform's architecture. You guys seem very reserved when it comes to any of the details. Nostr is a microblogging plaftorm comprised of relay operators running relay software and users running Nostr clients. Tor is a darknet platform comprised of volunteer node operators, volunteer directory authorities, and users who form onion circuits going therough the network in along an unpredictable route. Cloudflare is a content delivery network with servers all over the world and great protection against excessive traffic any website who they agree to host and work with.

What about you guys? Who are you? What service are you providing? Who is your platform is supposed to protect the privacy of? Viewers? Posters? Hosters? Yourselves? Is there anyone involved with your protocol that we are expected to trust and who we can't verify is tracking us? You said that your system provides privacy in addition to anonymity. How is it possible to provide privacy unless we already trust you? Are your servers somehow performing computations without being turned on, or sending communications without being connected to a network?

If you are going to start talking about such a fascinating topic and if you are going to pull such a bold take out of your ass where you claim to be better than Tor for privacy then you should give an explanation. You're leaving me hanging, I swear!

SimplifiedPrivacy.com 2mo ago

this info is all on our website and arweave's.

https://simplifiedprivacy.com/arweave/Arweave-QA/index.html

https://simplifiedprivacy.com/categories/arweave.html

Scoundrel 1mo ago 💬 1

You are assigning homework for the privilege of engaging with you? Are you unable to articulate the answers to any of my questions concisely? It sounds like you could use some practice!

SimplifiedPrivacy.com 1mo ago

Your strategy is to attack us, to try to get me to defend our work because you're too lazy to read the same content on our site. So you think you're going to save time by being aggressive.

The issue with this strategy, is that you come across as so negligent, immoral, and dumb, that our organization's staff doesn't care about your opinion to begin with.

Scoundrel 1mo ago 💬 2

It seems like you guys provide a shitcoi- I mean, a blockchain technology. Your platform exists to provide privacy to users and servers. However unlike Tor, in order to use your platform users have to choose a 3rd party server to place absolute trust in, and unlike Tor, your platform provides no way to determine the server won't be malicious. I got all that from what you linked. Did I get any of it wrong? Walk me through this.

SimplifiedPrivacy.com 1mo ago

It's not our platform. We are users of a protocol, and the protocol hosts the data. We're just doing website design for dynamic interaction with the protocol. Unlike Nostr, which blasts your IP when you use the protocol. With Arweave, one can pick any gateway they like and only that gateway sees it. One could use Tor with Arweave. The main point is it's divorced from physical locations

Scoundrel 1mo ago 💬 1

Who designed that protocol Mister "it's not our platform?"

With Tor, your exit node doesn't see your IP address, only your traffic. Only your guard node sees your IP address, and your guard node has no idea what websites you are visiting.

I would never use a service like Nostr without a VPN at the very least. I would never use a platform like Arweave either. Trusting a single person not to spy on you and share your data with third parties is not sufficient for my threat model or for Tor's threat model.

You say that I'm so negligent, immoral, and dumb that you don't care about my (quite well substantiated tyvm) beliefs. And yet I notice you still take the time to respond to me, which I appreciate.

SimplifiedPrivacy.com 1mo ago

The arweave foundation designed the protocol, not Simplified Privacy. Our app is similar to a nostr client, it's a tool to use a protocol. And you can use a VPN/Tor with Arweave, that's fine.