Replying to Avatar Sedj

If you say so. GM! I haven't had any fiber that I'm aware of in months. Haven't had a problem. Maybe it's because I'm also not ingesting the toxins.

The point is not to get into ketosis, at least not for me. Yes, in a general sense you want to be burning fat instead of carbs, and if you're strictly carnivore you will be in ketosis most or all of the time.

My point is to eliminate unnecessary things from my diet. greens, onions/garlic, aren't necessary for me. I've proven this for myself in the short term, and have heard enough anecdotal evidence to believe it should hold true for the much longer term. Is it the worst things ever to eat something green? Nope. I still sometimes use garlic and onion for seasoning, and sometimes I ingest them incidentally - but that is far different from eating full portions of them, and any toxins they do introduce are pretty quickly eliminated.

I actually look at it like most people regard desserts. We all know desserts aren't good for us, but we still indulge occasionally. In my world, same goes for EVERYTHING that isn't meat or dairy. If I really want to eat something like collard greens, then it should be as satisfying to me as fudge, cheesecake, or ice cream. And I should be aware that I am eating it for pleasure, not nutrition.

I've made this kind of exception for ceviche, chicken salad, banana bread, and cheesecake, as one-time events, not regular occurrences.

I'm just under no obligation to eat anything I don't actually want to eat, and I understand that everything I eat has consequences, even meat. Meat helps me stay on this side of the lawn each day. The rest of it really doesn't, unless I'm in some extreme situation where meat isn't available for a couple weeks. So what consequences do I choose?

The pork tenderloin leftover I ate for breakfast, cooked in lots of garlic and onion, basil, cilantro, carrots, lemon pepper, but served/stored without them, may speak for me.

Gm sedj ☕🌞 I see. Curious what led you to this diet? Seems like a very disciplined way to eat and i respect that. I think i have the discipline to do it for a while but dont want to long term for now. I like seeing how my energy changes (aka stabilizes lol) as I cut carbs (only to 20-30g/day tho). Carbs are v powerful in a bad way and most ppl have no idea. Also, do you test bloodwork, like hormone levels or cholesterol? I am getting some blood work done soon and even tho i cycle in and out of keto, i am curious to see my levels. But since i have been doing this, my energy, mood, motivation, happiness, etc has been top notch so def on the right path. I will try a couple days of just meat and dairy and report back.

Reply to this note

Please Login to reply.

Discussion

A lot of things led me here - dealing with the effects of not having a gall bladder, as well as lactose sensitivity, then post-COVID symptoms of not being able to handle cheese at all without paying for it almost immediately (within 5-15 minutes I was in the bathroom). I've always been interested in diets, and have explored various edits, like not eating any cheese, or not eating meat, or tracking everything I ate and trying to be under 1800 calories a day, sometimes below 1200. I didn't try all the diets out there, never thought Atkins or South Beach or eating grapefruits was going to be the right path. I ndidn't think replacing foods with food substitutes was a good idea either.

I'd read The Bitcoin Standard and The Fiat Standard, and heard what fake foods were about. I'd read lots of notes about seed oils. I actually haven't eaten at McDonalds since I was about 14 and learned that McDonalds had partnered with DuPont Chemical to develop edible plastics. I won't even drink a soda purchased from there. Personal ideological boycott

But when I started reading into carnivore options, a lot of it made sense and pulled together things I already knew. I read about half of The Bear's ridiculously huge monster thread on some old forum. It became apparent that although they may have some limited benefits, vegetables weren't necessary. Most of the stuff people eat vegetables for is to counteract the rest of their diet, including other vegetables. Sugars aren't necessary, but they are highly addictive. The idea of the caveman or paleo diet was interesting too, but those (as well as keto) all seemed to waver around things like fruits, nuts, and vegetables - and nobody stays on them for long, because they end up succumbing to sugar cravings that they bring on themselves through fructose.

Then there was taking a dive into history, how people ate over time. You don't have to look at mummified feces of proto-humans to make some basic observations. People ate meat first, and supplemented with seasonal vegetation as a last resort, or possibly as a treat. Fruit didn't stay ripe long enough to be a serious food source, and vegetables would rot once harvested. Meat was the renewable. Sugar was available in the form of honey (and cane in certain areas), but there was some serious risk involved in going after honey. Even a couple hundred years ago, people ate far less sweets, and most things didn't have sugars added. Now everything has sugar, corn syrup, or some kind of artificial sweetener. Grains are also fairly recently destroyed. And we've made all foods available all year around, everywhere, so we're eating the worst things all the time, instead of enjoying something less healthy as an occasional treat. We're filling up on glop instead of healthy protein, and as a result, we look the part.

I am not a "food is just fuel for the engine" type. I do believe in enjoying food, but enjoyment still needs to be secondary to utility. First I need to stay on the right side of the lawn, because otherwise the occasional treat becomes meaningless.

Going back to where this started, I actually wasn't really calling you out on vegetables. I was thinking more about the protein and nutritional density of chicken vs. beef. Chicken (and other birds) should be a fairly low percentage of your meat intake. Lack of fats is also a problem with chicken, and the goals of carnivore is actually more about eating enough fat. People who eat lots of chicken struggle with this, and not getting enough fat means they don't have the energy and don't lose the weight (whichever goal they are after), and they say it doesn't work. Same problem with keto/paleo/caveman. At least you have bacon fat in there. Chicken and turkey are not really good substitutes for red meat. Sure enough, your next meal was also a chicken dish. As I said, keto has a lot to learn; it isn't just keeping that carb number down. It is keeping the fats high, the proteins filling, and the other stuff off your plate, unless you want to continually fight sugar. Plants are still valuable, they are medicinal. I don't eat plants just like I don't eat aspirin, but sometimes they can help. They can also provide spice or flavor, although I think meat tastes fine without a lot of spice or extra flavors. Most of what we add to meat these days are sugar-spiked additions that do more to appease our sugar addiction than anything else.

You asked about bloodwork. YES! check yourself. But don't take the dr's interpretations too seriously. you SHOULD have high cholesterol. You should NOT have any high sugar numbers. I had full bloodwork done about a month in, and I was no longer pre-diabetic. I have been borderline most of my life. Same goes for whatever the indicator is for fatty liver disease - that is improving as well, although it was never more than borderline for me. Whatever the Drs point out, listen, then do some of your own research before taking any drugs. You don't want to be on statins or diuretics. The Dr will probably want you to go on a statin because of the cholesterol, but don't, do your research on this first, and determine if you believe that having high cholesterol is really a health risk if you are handling your insulin levels properly. I don't, and refuse to actually take the statin, regardless of what the good doc wants.

I'm probably getting more blood tests in a month or two, and I'm very curious about those results. You can also check your piss for ketones and such, but I don't see this as being all that helpful. If you're in carnivore ketosis, you'll be burning those ketones, not dumping them.

ah, i see about the chicken. it has been a v chicken-y week😂 also it's just raised p dirty regardless of organic and whatnot bc of corn and soy feed i guess. i have a good source of eggs that is soy and corn free plus pasture raised.

i have higher than "normal" cholesterol and as it is the base for every hormone i do not believe what docs say. and i have a friend who orders bloodwork for me and do my own analysis with a chemist who has looked at 100k+ results and i trust his view of what is health. being a bitcoiner, i def dont believe in handing the state of my health over to doctors. i would never compare myself to normal ranges 😵‍💫😂 those are based on very sick people too. i always aim for optimal not normal. and pleased you are not taking the statin. also have used a continuous glucose monitor quite a bit and my sugars are optimal.

def agree on being ancestrally consistent and how today's typical diet strays far! and our society def looks the part. cycling in and out of keto has made me aware of carbs' strong pull on neurochemistry too. always wonder how much "mental illness" would be resolved by cutting carbs.

for myself i havent fully decided where i stand on the necessity of carbs for a woman's hormone health. i have read positions on both sides and so far my own experience tells me that cycling is good. i am usually v dialed in.

also you might be interested in boston heart diagnostics and their sdLDL cholesterol and apoB tests for a more nuanced look at your lipids. idk but figured i would mention it.

so w/o a gall bladder, how are you handling fats? do you supp with digestive enzymes? amazing work getting that and lactose sensitivity under control with carnivore. ketones are v powerful anti inflammatories.

also i track ketones with a ketomojo. v reliable and has a GKI reading that tells how heavy of ketosis you are in. if you are ever interested in that sort of thing.

My house had a chicken week as well (at least my wife's cooking - then I came in with beef and pork).

There have been times in my life when I was obsessive about getting all the "data" I could about myself. Now isn't one of those times, I'm kind of opposite, figuring that anything I would gather would also be available for potentially anyone else to obtain, and I don't want the data out there to be shared with my friendly government or pharma institution (there isn't much separating those two right now). The standard blood tests are good enough to confirm any suspicions or point at any deficiencies. I believe I am aware of the boston hearth diagnostics tests - these are the tests looking at the size of the cholesterol molecules, rather than just the count, correct? As in, a high number of tiny cholesterol is way better than a much lower number of big cholesterol, if memory serves.

Right now I am considering the blood tests to be just a stopgap, really, making sure I'm not driving off a cliff, or at least letting there be some data for if things actually start going bad wrong. For my day to day, I'm much more interested in symptomology - how is my energy level, mood, and severity of any physical annoyances.

You asked about gall bladder and fats, and it was an early concern, but hasn't really been an issue. I can still need to find a bathroom quickly, but usually it can be traced to cheese/dairy, which is still an occasional issue, but has gotten better. I think the cheese thing is still a lingering post-Covid symptom, and cannot figure out what cheese(s) might be worse than others. Actually I don't think it really matters, because I can eat something with cheese one day, be fine, eat the same thing, same kind of cheese another day, and at least have some abdominal cramping. For now, I just enjoy cheese cautiously.

I don't know what "inflammation" really covers as far as symptoms and annoyances, but diet hasn't resolved all the things that I thought it might. However, nothing has gotten worse, except maybe some knee pain that may be due to actually straining something rather than just inflammation and eroded cartilage.

Interesting side effects - I am normally prone to sunburns. My sun resistance has gone way up. I think I've only used sunblock twice this summer, and haven't been painfully burnt. Second, body odor. I've never been a daily bather, and I know when I stink - but my sweat is not carrying the strong odor it once did. I think this is just the lack of salts, sugars, and yeasts in my body, as I don't really have any of that to sweat out. I may have to experiment with pillowcases, I've always been prone to turn them yellow over time, same with undershirts - and was told it was mostly a genetic thing. I'm wondering if it really has more of a basis in the chemistry of my sweat, which has certainly changed a bit.

I don't supplement. Actually, lies, I still take a multivitamin (Costco's daily multi, basically centrum), and a fish oil. And two blood pressure meds. I plan on stopping the multivitamin and fish oil for a while, once I run out, just to see how it goes. When I do that, I may decide it is time to eat more organ meats. I really haven't been, but I'm not against it.

I'm also considering trying to drop caffeine. I think that is still a long ways off, and just seems like more self-punishment than any benefit I would see at this point.

The cheese thing makes me think histamine. Aged cheeses have more. And it would fit the symptom too. Also knew ppl post covid that dealt with histamine intolerance. It isnt an allergy per se, just an immune system overload reaction.

Gonna do just red meat and dairy for the next few days 😎