Because the workforce that he needs is in the US. For as shit as our secondary and non-STEM undergraduate education system is in this country, an American post-graduate degree is still an aspiration for many of those foreigners. According to the NSF, data from last decade, 3/4 of those receiving PhDs remain in this country and secure H1B visas to work here.

Anecdotal evidence from folks I know currently going through PhD programs (physics and engineering) is that roughly 2% are Caucasian Americans. Most of the rest are foreigners. We simply don’t have enough people with an interest in becoming scientists and engineers to create the workforce that our more advantageous business environment demands to develop technical solutions.

When a foreigner has a 5-8 year track record (or longer as many do undergraduate degrees in the US as well) of living in this country, adapting to our ways and putting in the effort to receive a degree, why should we not allow them to work for a US company instead of exporting that sort of drive and education? Especially when it is lacking in so many of the young engineers born in this country.

Reply to this note

Please Login to reply.

Discussion

There are good reasons Americans aren't getting post graduate degrees in STEM, I know first hand. I wrote the first-of-its-kind automated engineering graduate application system and sat down with the Graduate Admissions Committee. They told me first hand, their process is broken. It was flooded with so many foreign applications, they simply couldn't process them all. At the time, they had a directive to prefer US citizens, but they simply couldn't find them because they were lost in the tens of thousands of foreign applicants. They needed to rely on recommendations from existing graduate students and first hand experience from professors, which would produce the result you would expect: The graduate students will always recommend friends, family and people from their own county. Now we have decades of this culture to the point where a nearly all the professors themselves are foreign born and have deep ties to overseas communities and they are making the decisions about who will study under them.

Don't give me this speculative bullshit about there not being enough citizens to fill the universities, the competition is simply too great and racism (whether explicit with DEI, or implicit with nepotism) is a significant hurdle to enter most programs in public universities