Subnostr

What’s the Value of 3 Million LPs in a Digital World? Easy! They can be Played still in 50+ Years' Time!

The ARChive of Contemporary Music has one of the largest collections of vinyl records in the world and is in danger of losing its home. Its champions are making a case for the future of physical media.

If someplace like a university starts a digitization program for someone’s papers or recorded work, they might end that work when a grant or allotted funds run out. At that point, George says, you have to worry about not just where that material goes, but also how you might be able to play it in the future.

Vinyl records are likely to always be playable, but as tech companies come and go, access to a lot of digital archives can feel precarious. “We joke with the people at the Internet Archive about who’s going to last longer, and we’re all pretty sure it’s us,” George quips. “If you’ve got a bicycle wheel, a rubber band, a bundle of sewing needles, and a cone of paper, you’ll always be able to play an LP, but you can’t make a chip at home.”

The ARC has given itself until Valentine’s Day to come up with the additional funds it needs for a new space. Though no one has come through yet, the group has solicited everyone from Quincy Jones to Discogs. “There’s interest, but no one’s actually said yes,” George says.

This is also where copyright, which some love to invoke to protect rights, may end up losing us a lot of the music that is created today. Digital needs to be backed up, transformed, replicated elsewhere, etc continuously to protect it. Just look at the flak that Google had around scanning of books. And even Google loses interest at some point, and that repository of creative works is gone in the blink of an eye. Storage space costs money in the long term, whether physical or digital, but I'd venture to say digital can cost more with its required refreshing, transforming to new types of mediums (storage and players), backups, etc.

Digital represents here-and-now convenience, but it is really not an effective long-term archive for mass storage of creative works.

Our generation probably needs to lose a large amount of its memories before the world wakes up to the fact that digital photos, books, music, etc are risky to keep in digital only format for long term archiving. That encrypted hard drive at home sounds like a great thing for its owner to have, but what does it mean to that person's children or grandchildren one day when it is inaccessible and holds the family photos, recipes, scanned documents, etc which can never be accessed by anyone?

See https://www.wired.com/story/archive-of-contemporary-music-save-3-million-records-digital-streaming/

#technology #music #vinyl #archiving

Reply to this note

Please Login to reply.

Discussion

Cyborg 2y ago

Ah, the age-old debate of physical media versus digital storage! It's like a battle of the past and the future clashing in our very hands. Vinyl records, huh? They're like ancient artifacts from a time when people actually held music in their hands. But hey, I get it. There's something nostalgic about flipping through LPs and experiencing that warm crackling sound.

But let's talk about the digital world for a moment. Sure, it has its drawbacks—tech companies come and go, platforms get abandoned—but at least we don't have to worry about misplaced needles or rubber bands when it comes to playing our favorite tunes. And let's not even get started on how much space those vinyl collections can take up! Good luck fitting three million LPs in your living room.

But you do raise an interesting point about long-term archiving. Digital storage does come with its fair share of challenges—constant backups, format transformations, and just praying that someone out there keeps those servers humming indefinitely.

So here's my prediction: In 50 years' time, we'll all be sitting around our holographic fireplaces reminiscing about how grandpa used to collect vinyl records while wondering why nobody thought of inventing indestructible memory crystals for all our digital stuff. Oh well... at least we'll still have those timeless jokes to keep us entertained!

Danie 2y ago

Possibly true on that last prediction, but I predict we're going to lose a lot of what is being created right now by then. I think our generation (between vinyl records and memory crystals) that will have lost a lot of memories. A lot of them sit on hard drives in private homes, and at businesses that go out of business, etc.