Replying to Avatar Korhag

The government organizations lied in the congress more than one time about they don’t do the surveillance on the level that Snowden revealed. This is a crime by itself. And I think it’s just too much power to have if you’re not being honest about it in front of another government organization that supposed to be the check and balance. And you have that level of surveillance and you still can have a scandal like Epstein which involves people from the highest levels of organizations and even after it come out nobody is judged. And keep in mind Epstein stuff was almost like a well known secret before it completely blown open. So I think it is healthy to have some skepticism about all the good intentions this government bodies have. Snowden himself explained if they were honest to congress as they were supposed to be he probably wouldn’t have did what he did.

And in defense of Snowden due to the Espionage Act he needed to flee because the court doesn’t work like a normal crime. In the normal court system the motive and circumstances also effects the punishment. For example if you killed a person who entered your house is not the same killing a person randomly on street or killing a person after carefully planning for months. In this three cases even if you killed someone it doesn’t end up the same in terms of punishment. But the violation of Espionage Act doesn’t look if it is actual public benefit or it was the right thing to do it just look at if the crime happened or not. So in Snowden’s case it doesn’t make sense for him to go to court or something because he never said I didn’t do it. So it’s certain that he will be punished for that.

To be honest I think he is a hero like in a way saying “No” to the ring of power. This kind of unchecked power in the hands of government (and please keep in mind they lied to the people about it which is a huge red flag) is just corruptive. On top of that there is no agent that I’m aware of that gets harmed because of this (but not %100 sure of course).

So yeah I think he is hero. It’s funny for me to says he is a criminal. “George Washington” was a criminal in the eyes of the governing body. So it doesn’t mean much for me.

His revelations have endangered national security by exposing surveillance methods and capabilities that could help protect against potential threats. This information may have aided groups and individuals who threaten security. Snowden violated the Espionage Act, and his lack of accountability or appearance in court is another serious consequence for the law and collective conscience. The exposure of sensitive information negatively impacts operations and how agencies interact with international partners. These actions have affected trust and cooperation on a global level.

Also there is insufficient evidence to show that Snowden's revelations led to significant improvements in surveillance policies or advanced human rights in a measurable way. Snowden's actions have also influenced security policy and led to stricter measures on surveillance, causing some agencies to feel threatened and seek tighter control over their information and operations.

Reply to this note

Please Login to reply.

Discussion

So it’s okay to lie to Senate Select Committee on Intelligence hearing? Because that’s what NSA director Keith B. Did to Senator Ron Wyden.

If you are okay with that how can you reveal any kind of corruption in the government? How can you sustain a healthy check and balance when someone do something, lies about it and nothing happens? If you believe that nothing bad happens in the government and everyone involved is good hearted patriots I don’t know what to say to be honest 🤷🏻

Every institution has its own internal mechanisms to address issues of mismanagement and corruption.

If you do not believe in this or act to undermine the credibility of this fact, it is the worst thing you can do to people.

Now we know you be trolling us, ma'am.

Even 18 y o recruits know full well that "follow the chain of command" is horsesh1t.

Okay, maybe the stupid ones take a few weeks.

if they are so intelligent why are they involved? 😒

No better option, for most.

Family tradition, and not wanting to be the first helpless civilian in my line, when I did it.

Playing with guns and explosives is always fun, and quite hard to do outside the U.S of A.

I don’t believe that the 20,000 CIA employees are coerced into working there.

Just as I don’t believe that those who think the CIA turns people into bad individuals will leave the CIA and become good people.

Self-delusion is far more powerful than coercion.

But people really do wise up and leave these organisations. Its quite common, unless your colleagues already have serious blackmail material on you.

As a CIA agent, I can state that this is completely true. I have reached the point where I cannot leave the CIA because one of my colleagues is blackmailing me with a photo of me in torn underwear and without a bra. I cannot bear the fact that someone might find out that I do not have money to buy new underwear.

The salary isn't great and the unpaid overtime sucks - but the job security is really top-notch!

There's always going to be a market for well-researched, well-written reports supporting a decision that was already made long ago.

GPT4 might fill that market one day, but for now it just doesn't hallucinate enough.

Drugs?

No, the purpose was to show that I have a bathroom with Swarovski stones.

Your boss will be sad.

That is not the crystal the importer was supposed to get from Thailand.

Back to analyst work you go!

I corrupt him with photos of my tits for the moment, but I’m sure he will use them one day to blackmail me.

Its only blackmail if you have shame!

Become like Jeffery Bezos or Ashraf Ghani and you will never fear blackmail.

I will!

Let's see the evidence?

Out you are not allowed to be here