When my mempool does what I want, I do not consider it kneecapped, but well formed
And I want my mempool to eject most spam, because spam uses my system's resources for harm instead of for good
Discussion
Do you close your door at home?
Why? thieves can enter in 30 seconds
Sure, but filtering your mempool isn’t a lock, it’s a blindfold. The “thieves” still get in, you’ve just chosen not to see them.
Allowing easy generation of transactions with SPAM, and certifying that this is permitted and normalized through the use of OP_RETURN, doesn't seem like a great idea to me. I can already see the plugin for Sparrow Wallet or Electrum that allows adding images with two lovers kissing in the OP_RETURN field.
LOL bro these 'plugin's' existed years before v30 in the form of degenerate ordinal wallets. Offering these types of user an alternative solution that can be less harmful to node operators isn't a bad thing.
The main problem is that fee incentives don't align with pushing this behaviour.
I know the problem of the utxo set and I'm partially agree with you, but I think filters are better than no filters.
This is my opinion.