Nostr Web Client

I remember when the Ukrainiam war broked out, on the eBay were campaigns to help the Ukrainain orphans. In the campaingns were listed children's drawings to buy or bid. So every listed items contained a description that they will not deliber the physical item. When you bought one of them you supported whe orphans only, without getting anything. As a result the same item was listed many times. And you paid via e.g. PayPal, regardless using ebay trough browser or via the app.

Therefore the listed item can be treated as an NFT.

So if you want to get zapped you should list your "physical" drawing you made it, for bidding, without deliver the item. Any opinion about this "solution"?

5192b2e2... 2y ago

Be it BTC ordinals or ERC721's, no matter what it is, ultimately you can't actually ensure some nonfungible asset not being copied, you can only ensure that your asset is going to be central in the sense of guaranteed data availability over a long span of time (or basically forever, for an ordinal as an example, or a fully onchain 721).

Otherwise for physical assets you need delivery or legally binding arrangements to guarantee some piece is yours. There is no way to not allow someone to relist a piece for now, although I could imagine that a mitigation strategy would be an AI trained to recognize and output an identifier for one nonfungible asset, and then compare on-chain whether that asset has been delivered already to someone or not.

Reply to this note

Please Login to reply.

Discussion

ᴄʏʙᴇʀɢᴜʏ 👽 2y ago

Ok, but forget the "real" NFT's :-) because Apple doesn't allow to pay for an NFT without using the ApplePay. Otherwise they can not get their percent regardig the payment.

As you mentioned the physical items must be delivered or contracted about the ownership. It this case the full donation campaign for Ukrainian children was illegal, because phisically the same items were relisted despite of that the actual "buyer" already paid for it (this was the donation).

On the other hand in many cases when you list an item in ebay, it doesn't mean that the photo is about the actual item you listed. So there is no chance to identify the actual item (see not just eBay, but Aliexpress or Alibaba).