I’ve been thinking about the idea of a “web of trust layer.”

A “layer” is basically a NIP-51 list of pubkeys where you associate each pubkey with a WoT score, like this:

[“p”, , ]

The idea is that you can have distinct “layers” with WoT scores that are calculated using distinct algos and can even have distinct data formats. Then different layers can be used for different purposes. One layer might be used to stratify content as is already being implemented by Pablo in #Wikifreedia or by me at brainstorm.ninja. Other layers could be used to supply the weights for doing weighted averages or other calculations. You could even have a system where Layer A is utilized in the determination of Layer B.

I don’t think we’d even need a new NIP for this, since NIP-51 already supports extra data fields (if I recall correctly).

Thoughts?

Reply to this note

Please Login to reply.

Discussion

Have you talked with Ron Stoner about this? I bet he could be an intellectual Swiss Army knife for this project.

I don’t think so - is he on nostr?

He has like a ton of followers

And now he has one more!

I wish I had like a ton of followers

Maybe I should just stick to making t shirts

see there’s one now! Take that, AI !!

Yes, he’s a security expert or reptilian alien who hacked a way to get 1M followers on nostr in 24 hours. He seems skeptical about the Web of Trust concept but I imagine he could add a lot of technical know-how since you have the practical details laid out and aren’t just saying “wen web of trust”.

nostr:npub1qjtnsj6hks7pq7nh3pcyv2gpha5wp6zc8vew9qt9vd2rcpvhsjjqydz44v

Security expert or reptilian alien?

Ron has at some point in his career said this

If the event is broadcastable it can be manipulated. Would it be a relay only list? Or would the relays need a centralized coordinator?

Manipulation of a nostr event? The digital signature would no longer match. Not sure I understand what you mean.

Meaning what stops me from using (or influencing) pubkey B through Z to sign and broadcast a list containing pubkey A with a positive score?

You mean what prevents you from launching a sybil attack where you spin up pubkeys B through Z for the purpose of promoting pubkey A?

if pubkeys B through Z were launched by someone else and you are somehow influencing them, that’s a very different scenario