https://new.nostr.band/note1d933xkgmxm45q2x02pmyzv6wlm7zmyze89f34txfeajuzrxy8h8s8ldq7m
Discussion
tldr; people who have not ran or tried running a community saying it's a feature not a bug...
can we stop saying "feature not a bug" without objectively considering alternatives 
It's stupid really. You are taking the choice out of person's hands. So what, I am supposed to automatically broadcast everything I post in other communities, all the music I listen to, the streams I am watching? Have a share button... sure, but not automatically broadcast it.
I can't control what a client displays, but I don't want to see random non-community replies in my community. Nor would I want to spam my followers with content not intended for them because they don't share those interests.
writes a private email
it suddenly gets broadcasted to your public facebook feed
"feature not a bug, ser"
Imo it should stay kind 1s but clients should differentiate between community posts and normal notes and not show the former.
that doesn't solve the problem of broadcasting content to followers who may not care about that content
Hm yeah
What makes communities special is that a group of people share the same interest and you feel a sort of a bond there. You can talk about things and people get it, unlike the general population. Besides, it can be weird stuff that most people won't relate to. I think it's really important that people have to join communities to participate in them, even if it's something as trivial as clicking a join button. Otherwise it's not really a community and you're broadcasting your random niche interests to everyone.
agree with this so much 