What’s the purpose of paying a relay?

Reply to this note

Please Login to reply.

Discussion

How many spammers do you think will pay? Not many, so your chances of receiving spam from from a paid relay are way less than from free ones.

I see. So the higher the fee, the lower the spam?

Hopefully.

Prepare for 1BTC subscription relais.

Nostr Plebs has made roughly 1M sats over the past few days from spammers. Spammers will pay.

Sure, but much less. So it's easier for an admin to stay on top of.

And the financial incentive for the relay runner to keep it clean should also help.

Time is a limited resource, and you are right, people will be willing to pay to get some of that time on their spam/product/idea/whatever.

Increase prices?

Nah!

Do you think is a solution to spamming? My feeling says no.

I think it's part of the picture. Spammers are going to spam though and so long as there's free and open relays and clients that allow unfiltered content (I can't see either going anywhere anytime soon) it's going to continue.

The client I'm building has some other options for filtering, and I'm sure others are doing similar. You can require a certain amount of proof-of-work (see NIP13) on any notes/messages that come from people you don't follow. That adds a cost for a spammer to create thousands of posts that will actually get through the filter, but is a trivial amount of work for a single note or other event. The client itself also adds PoW to your own notes.

Fixes 99% of the problem with 1% effort, at least for now.

I agree with #[2] , sooner or later clients will use PoW to fight spam