Imagine a currency for an off-grid society where there is no internet and only peer to peer communication. How would a digital currency look like?

After some thought, that currency might be "time". You ask someone else to perform an action in exchange for their time in return.

Person A gives NN minutes of their life to person B in exchange for XYZ.

This means person A takes a commitment (signed digitally) to provide NN minutes of service to person B at a mutually agreed task (e.g. planting potatoes, harvesting, etc).

Such debt can be given to others. Person B gives minutes from person A to person C which can now demand those minutes to be serviced. All with digital proof of receipts when completed on both sides.

This system has faults, just remember that we are talking about an imperfect digital world without internet. It would work reasonably well on small communities where some level of trust is to be expected.

What are your thoughts? Would it work?

Reply to this note

Please Login to reply.

Discussion

An off grid community does not need it's own currency.

It's called a gift economy.

I grow enough corn to share, my neighbour collects enough eggs from their chickens to share.

The hunter collects enough meat to share with the tribe, and so on.

Currency is only useful for trade outside of the community.

In which case Bitcoin would make the most sense

No internet available and bitcoin is an artificial asset that only a few souls will have.

Whereas everyone here is born with time, even when they have nothing else to give you.

Like if you got debts within a community it's not a real community it's just some people trying to exploit each other.

When you're part of a community you have a duty to serve the community, no financial incentives or punishments necessary, and in turn the community cares for you.

A community should ideally function like a family.

I'm not talking about a small community, we are looking at up to 100 people per location.

It gets difficult to keep a tally of who owns what and when. The kumbaya lifestyle where everyone has good sense doesn't scale.

If you work for a week planting the field of someone, you need payment for that. Attention that time can be traded for other goods when both parties agree. Also, time from diferent people has different values. You might work the fields for a week and just get 60 minutes as payment reward from someone important.

Bluetooth blockchain ledger

The Pegged stablecoin could be a solution

Who would issue such coins between two people without internet?

Why use time and not chance (perceived as luck) as a valuation basis?

Luck has no value because it is not measurable.

If you own someone else one hour of work, the other person will see value in using your effort for an hour in the future.

That is measurable and valuable.

This presumes the value of labour would be more quantifiable than luck. I contest that. The valuation of labour is complex. The valuation of luck is binary. You won, or you didn't.

Then explain how to trade luck units.

Because explaining that you own someone else an hour of work is far simple by comparison.

Please let's avoid edge cases because the system has limitations. If you own me 10 minutes of work and there a contract proving it, that is something measurable and with value.

Thank you. Now I understand that concept and provided feedback.

On this case is different because each living person is their treasury that can issue bonds for their own currency, which on this case is time.

So in theory one person can issue thousands of hours in debt. The question is if the market (buyers) will see value in accepting those hours (bonds) and if the issuer (person) is deemed as capable enough to pay the debts (work on behalf of the bond owner).

Some peoples time is more valuable than others. Some tasks can be done in the same time but vary drastically in difficulty and demand. While time is always a variable, it can't be the sole one

Yes, fully agree. Before performing the task, the time payment is agreed.

Even if you harvest a field for a full week, you might only end up with 60 minutes from the other person.