Admin of todon.nl, and rightly so, suggests the default/flagship Mastodon instance (isn’t decentralisation great?) be moved to a more neutral jurisdiction than Germany:

“Herewith the urgent request to move the Mastodon server presented to new users as the default (mastodon.social) to a more neutral jurisdiction (e.g. Switzerland). An alternative is to set up a new Mastodon server in a more neutral jurisdiction, which can then serve as a new flagship server.

The trigger for this is the regular negative moderation of people who speak out against the largest and bloodiest genocide of our time, the one in Palestine. In particular they use (or abuse, how you want to look at it) of a German law that seeks to counter so-called Holocaust reversal. With hiding behind this law, the moderators of mastodon.social (and especially its owner) are also unwittingly sitting in the chair of the (German) judge.

Apart from the fact that one local law should not affect the entire Mastodon project, the question is whether this law and the concept of Holocaust reversal are legally tenable in an international context.”

https://github.com/mastodon/mastodon/discussions/34747

Mastodon mod closes the ticket after stating that “There is no current plan to make changes to the Mastodon instances operated by Mastodon gGmbH. People are free to choose any Mastodon server when signing up for the platform.”

And this is what that “choice” looks like (and this – along with the fact that they didn’t close registrations after hitting a certain size to create a social precedent and allow distribution to other servers – is why there is a flagship instance – an absolute contradiction of terms in a system that purports to be decentralised.)

#fediverse #mastoson #mastodonSocial #todonNL #Germany #israel #genocide #ethnicCleansing #apartheid #settlerColonialism #Palestine #Gaza

Reply to this note

Please Login to reply.

Discussion

Problem with mastodon centralization is not in one specific default server. Centralization problem is in protocol. You are only on one server where you have accout . You can see and comunicate with others, but you are only on one. So you have multiple centers. Its polycentric network not decentralized. Censorship is easy for country where is server with your account. If they force server to remove your account with all data you lost everything and you need to build your social network from ground.

Decentralized is when your account with all your data is on multiple servers.

If your account is on nostr, your data are by default on multiple relays(servers). Is some of them in germany? Who cares about their censorship when you are on another x relays and all content is on every one of them. They force german server to remove your notes? It's not effective.