I just now discovered this BIP proposal. I also don't think this is a good idea.

In my view I there's many more important things to do in the world and ways to spend attention and capital. But anybody is free to create a BIP. And I think its important to always remember that the idea that all BIPs should deserve attention per se and all appear in one place is obviously just an opinion as we know. It's part of the process of decentralization that we're all part of.

This (and other BIP ideas) are a great test to the decentralization of Bitcoin. Bitcoin should remain decentralized, and we should find ways to make that decentralization always be the priority.

Bitcoin is the community. Nostr allows that community to flourish too. Nostr can also teach decentralization to Bitcoin.

We're all going to there and learn a lot about all of this. We're gonna get there.